Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
The Virginia Gazette Letter to Editor September 30, 1773
What is this article about?
Robert Carter Nicholas, in a letter to the printers Purdie & Dixon, defends Virginia's paper currency against the criticisms of 'A Virginian', arguing that the emissions were necessary during wartime, were secured by adequate funds, and that exchange fluctuations were driven by trade balance rather than paper money itself.
Quality green show the numbers
- Mean ink quality
- 99.0% The length-weighted average confidence across the OCR lines — the mean of exactly the per-line scores whose tails the two figures below report. Typical is 99%.
- Illegible ink
- 0.0% Text sitting in OCR-detected lines that scored below 80% confidence — very shaky reads. Weighted by line length, so one long bad line counts for more than a short one.
- Uncertain ink
- 0.0% Text in lines that scored 80–90% — somewhat shaky reads.
- Matches source
- 95.64% How closely the served text matches the raw OCR of the same boxes, letter by letter, after collapsing spacing and case. This measures agreement, not correctness: the OCR is often wrong and the extractor corrects it, so 100% does not mean perfect, and a low figure usually means poor scan text was rewritten rather than that text was lost (length vs source shows loss). Across pages, this is the worst fragment.
- Length vs source
- 99.27% Below 100% means text was dropped from the OCR; above means text was added to make it read.
- Transcription confidence
- 93.0% (typical 96%) How cleanly the extractor could assemble what it was given. Low here with clean ink scores points at layout analysis — the characters were read correctly but grouped or ordered wrongly.
- Comprehension
- 92.0% Whether the piece reads coherently start to finish. Can stay high while transcription confidence drops, when only part of the component is affected.
Full Text
GENTLEMEN, WILLIAMSBURG, September 22, 1773.
THE very earnest Address of your Correspondent, "A Virginian," on the Subject of Paper Money unquestionably demands our most serious Attention; especially as it comes warmly recommended by so respectable a Number of your Readers in the County of Stafford. That we ought to profit from the Experience of others, it must be owned, is a Lesson sanctified by the Voice of Wisdom; the Observation, from its Antiquity, hath, long since, become proverbial; but, give me Leave to remark that, in most political Reformations, it is often observable that the Zeal of the Reformer is too apt to hurry him beyond the Object of his Wishes and may introduce Inconveniencies, which he hardly foresees and may live to lament. Of this Sort I must consider the Essay, which is the Subject of my present Contemplation. The Author's extreme Aversion to every Kind of Paper Currency may be, in his own Opinion, well founded, and he has displayed too large a Share of good Sense to admit a Suspicion that he could have wished to depreciate what Paper Money we have now remaining in Circulation, but yet it is to be feared that his Observations may have this Tendency. I will, for a Moment, suppose the original Evil in first admitting it amongst us to have been, even as great as he would represent it; but surely we are now called upon by every Principle of Justice, by every Dictate of political Wisdom, to support its Credit; should this fail, the Confusion the Country may be thrown into and the Losses, which may be sustained by Individuals, the present Possessors of the Money, are more easily to be conceived than described.
Having, on a late Occasion, given the Publick what appeared to me a faithful History of our Paper Currency, from its first Introduction, I should now leave the Author's Observations on our former Emissions unnoticed, were it not to be apprehended that the Want of a thorough Understanding of the Subject may mislead some of your Readers and lay a Foundation of groundless Prejudices. That other Countries, as well as Virginia, have sustained Inconveniencies and, perhaps, Losses from a Paper Currency, I am not at all concerned to deny; what I undertake to maintain is that these have not arisen from Paper Money, merely, as such, but that they have been chiefly, if not totally owing, either to these Bills of Credit not being established upon proper Funds, or to a Superabundance of them, or to some Mismanagements. I might, if the Limits of your Paper would permit, go farther and show clearly that other Countries have derived great Advantages from Paper Currencies and that the Business of those Communities would be vastly cramped and could not be transacted to Advantage without them. In doing this I should take into my View the different Banks; some established immediately by, and others, under the Auspices of publick Authority; some upon one and others upon different Kinds of Funds, and might ask, with Propriety, what are the Notes issuing from those Banks more or less than Paper Money? Gentlemen, whose Eyes are captivated and so much allured by the Glitter of the precious Metals, as hastily to pronounce every other Species of Money counterfeit, will do well to consider more distinctly the Nature of Money, and what is its proper Office. The original Commerce of the World we know, was carried on merely by Barter; Work was paid in Work and one Species of Goods exchanged for another. As Nations became more civilized and Commerce more extensive, it was found convenient and necessary to fix a certain Price upon some particular Things, as a Measure and Standard for all others. Gold, Silver, Copper and Brass, being the more scarce and noble Metals, were agreed upon by the common Consent of most Nations; though it is equally well known that Iron, Leather, Paper and many other Things, having a certain Stamp impressed upon them to denote their Value, have been adopted and passed currently in many Countries as Money, and in some of them been preferred even to Gold or Silver. From the most celebrated Authors we learn that Money, in Respect to its proper Office, is to be considered as no more than a "Ticket or Counter, a mere Representation of a Commodity in its Absence, which, if we had it in our Possession, we would readily exchange for another we might have Occasion for." It must, however, be acknowledged that the Species of Money, whose Value is universal, is much to be preferred, though not in Exclusion of all other Kinds, I mean such as may be substituted as its Representative. In some Countries the Quantity of Specie, as it is commonly called, is found inadequate to the Demands of Commerce and the Purposes of Government. Hence the Necessity of some Sorts of Paper Currency, and, when this is established upon competent Funds and properly managed, Experience proves that it fully answers the Purposes of Gold and Silver, especially for transacting the internal Business of a Country, and that, in some Respects, it has superior Advantages. Payments are made with much greater Facility and the Paper is much more portable. It is indeed subject to Forgeries, a Misfortune much to be lamented by us, but to be ascribed, in a great Measure, to our Inexperience; the Want of such proper Paper, as is used with good Success in other Countries, which we could not procure at first, and which we did not afterwards provide, hoping that every Emission would be the last. But, I beseech you, are not the precious Metals almost equally exposed to Counterfeits? And are not these Counterfeits in general more difficult to be detected? For Answer to this Question I beg Leave to refer to the different authentick Accounts we have received from most Parts of the World of the State of their several Coins and the almost numberless Forgeries of it, which have been discovered. Besides this the metallick Coins are frequently depreciated by Clippings, Sweatings, and a Number of other Tricks, which the Ingenuity, or greater Wickedness of Men, have invented. Thus much premised;
I take the Liberty, since the Necessity of the Measures formerly adopted by this Country seem obliquely as that of some late Transactions is directly questioned, once more to remind your Readers of the Circumstances we were in, when our Paper Money was first introduced. Attacked, as we were in all Quarters by a most powerful, in Conjunction with a most savage and barbarous Enemy; when our Country was in the most imminent Danger and we had to contend for all that was dear and valuable, could we possibly have looked supinely on and suffered every Thing to go to Destruction? Had this been our Plan, the County of Stafford, I am persuaded, would speedily have become a Frontier, and with the lower Counties, would, soon afterwards, have fallen a Victim to the Enemy. Under these Circumstances, what was to be done? Money, the acknowledged Sinews of War, was necessary, immediately necessary; Troops could not be levied and supported without it; of Gold and Silver, there was indeed some, what Quantity I do not know, in the Hands of Individuals, but the Publick could not command it. Did there not result from hence a Necessity, an absolute Necessity of our having Recourse to a Paper Currency, as the only Resource, from which we could draw Relief? Perhaps we might have furnished more than our just Quota, but it was not a Time for us to have stood upon nice Calculations with our Sister Colonies. Let us next consider what was the Nature of this Paper Money and how it was established, Not being able to procure Specie in Time. it was resolved to issue Treasury Notes, which were to pass current according to the Value of their Denominations expressed in each Note; these were to be redeemed in a few Years, and to secure their Redemption a Land and Poll Tax; a Duty on Tobacco; a Tax on Writs and Ordinary Licences and on Wheel Carriages was imposed; the Notes were issued at different Times, as Exigencies required, and were redeemable at several Periods. The Author of the Address doth not deny, but seems to admit the Sufficiency of the Funds; indeed, I believe, it was never questioned, so that the Notes became current throughout this, and, I understood, were in exceeding good Credit in the neighbouring Colonies. Had the Business of our Treasury been properly managed (that it was not I am sure I have been far from wishing to conceal) all these Notes would have been long since cancelled and destroyed. But surely an after Misconduct in Office, in a particular Instance cannot operate as a general Objection against Paper Currencies, unless the Author will suppose that the Dispositions of all Men are alike and that Abuses are not to be corrected and guarded against. The Author's Strictures upon this Mismanagement, I own, are too justly founded, and, could it now answer any good Purpose, I would readily join him in repeating my Censures of it. Individuals have felt the fatal Effects and I have no Doubt but the Community sustained a Loss by Exchange being kept up. But, with me, there are proper Times and Seasons for all Things. The Assembly took the earliest Opportunity of fixing a proper Stigma on this Misconduct, which I hope will be a Warning to others; they did Justice to the Country in exacting the utmost Retribution and by endeavouring to guard against the like Mischiefs in future; if any Thing farther can be added or done to give a more general Satisfaction or the least farther Security to the Publick, in the Name of Justice to the Community, let it be done without Loss of Time and without Respect of Persons. But let us not, instead of alleviating and making the best of former Misfortunes, so far as may consist with Justice, suffer them to mar every future Endeavour to retrieve them. It is from this Period I have wished to look forward, having a proper Regard to every Thing that preceded it. The Quantity of Paper Money issued, in the Course of the late War was very considerable, having exceeded Half a Million, which perhaps was more than this Country could have conveniently borne, if it could have been avoided; it may point out one of the Inconveniencies I have mentioned, arising from a Superabundance of such Sort of Money, but cannot, as I conceive, militate against a Paper Currency altogether. That so large a Quantity of Paper Money contributed to raise Exchange, I will freely own as my Opinion; though, at the same Time, I am thoroughly persuaded that the Balance of Trade being so much against us was the chief governing Cause of it. That, as a necessary Consequence of a high Exchange, the Prices of foreign Goods were enhanced, I will not deny, though I must take the Liberty to differ in Opinion with the Author in his Estimate of the Losses the Country sustained, which he makes amount to 200,000l. One material Circumstance he seems to have overlooked. A very just Position of his own (which he considers in Theory, and Experience shows that it generally holds also in Practice) is "that the Price of Provisions and Labour must increase in Proportion to the Increase of Money;" if he had added Tobacco, Bills of Exchange, and every other vendible Commodity, I would have agreed with him that the Prices of all these Things are very considerably increased by the Increase of Money, though he must allow that other Circumstances frequently combine to effect this Increase of Price. How did the Case stand then between the Merchant and Vender of these Commodities and the Planter and Purchaser? The Quantity of Money raised Exchange and of Course the Price of foreign Goods, so that the Planter paid more for them; than he would have done; But, on the other Hand, the Planter, because of the great Quantity of Money, received more for his Commodities, than he otherwise would have done, whether he was allowed for them in Discount on the Books of the Merchant with whom he dealt, or sold them for ready Money. Another Thing probably happened, which Men are not always aware of, in the Course of these Transactions, namely that the very Debts contracted with the Merchants sometimes, under peculiar Circumstances, might have operated as an Addition to the Quantity of Money, by increasing the Competition amongst Buyers for the Planter's Commodities; in other Instances, where People were distressed, the contrary Effect might take Place. I am not able to state an exact Account of Profit and Loss between the Merchant and Planter in these Transactions; I have had my Fears that the Planters, upon the Whole, were Losers, but nothing in Comparison of what the Author supposes. The plain and simple Matter of Fact the different Inhabitants of this Country are able to judge of, whether greater Prices were not given for Tobacco and the other Produce of their Estates during the War and for several Years after, than they had been accustomed to; from every Account I have heard I believe this was the Case; I know it was so, in my own private Concerns. But let the Expences and Losses sustained by the Emission of our Paper Notes have been as great as the Author would represent, I must consider them altogether as the Price of that Security and Happiness we now enjoy; and whoever recollects the Dangers and Distresses, to which the Country, particularly our Frontiers were exposed, I am persuaded that he must, upon the Whole, acknowledge it to have been an advantageous Purchase. Perhaps some Men of very frugal, parsimonious Dispositions, impressed by the galling Ideas of Expence, may view this Part of the Subject in the same Light that some Patients, recovered from long and dangerous Illness, may do their Physician's and Apothecary's Bills; in the Extremity of their Danger they would have given the whole World, had it been at their Command, for the Assistance of some healing Hand; but, now the Danger is all over, the Doctor is almost forgotten, his Charges complained of and perhaps his Account disputed, however reasonable in other Men's Opinions. Who were the few Individuals alluded to, as alone reaping "temporary Advantages" from this Paper Money, I do not know; the Printer and others concerned in preparing the Notes had a moderate Allowance and the late Treasurer received a Commission; but the whole Expence, did not, if my Information is right, amount to one fifth Part of what it would have done in a neighbouring Colony; after the Money was issued for publick Services, and Expences, I suppose particular Men, in the Course of its Circulation, might have made the same Advantages with it, as they would have done with any other Sort of Money. What "great Disorder In the State" could have happened to reduce this Money to nothing I cannot divine, unless it would equally have stripped every Owner of his Gold and Silver; if the Currency, as every one must be satisfied, who is acquainted with this Country, must have stood or fallen with it, I should suppose, in this Respect, at least, that it was as valuable and had as great a Degree of Permanency as could have been wished.
I have not been able to procure a Sight of Mr. Pittman's Account of Louisiana, or any other Author, who treats upon the same Subject, so that I cannot judge to what Cause it was owing that "Paper Money had almost effected the Ruin of that Province;" but I must suppose it was owing either to the Want of a proper Establishment of their Notes, or to some Redundancy of them; it should have been shown that they were established upon Funds equally good and sure as ours, or else the Example is not applicable. Your Correspondent, from the Disparity of the Cases, is surely rather unfortunate in the other two Instances held forth, as Beacons, to warn us of our Danger. Can the "Paper Credit, which lately produced such extensive Injuries in Great Britain," with any Sort of Propriety, be compared to our Paper Money? Some private Bankers, it seems, upon mere Speculation; had for a Number of Years circulated their own Notes for immense Sums of Money, some Hundred Thousand Pounds, we are told, more than their real Capitals; this succeeded for a Time, but, as it must have happened in the Nature of Things, the Bubble burst at last and the Secret was betrayed. What happened in the Massachusetts's Government might indeed serve as a Caution to us, if there was the most distant Probability of our falling into their political Errours; but I am sure nothing of this Sort is to be apprehended from any Measures hitherto pursued. This Opinion I may venture to say is justified by the Reluctance and Disinclination shown by our Assembly to the issuing very moderate Sums in the three last Instances, though Cases of Necessity, as well as by their rejecting every Proposal, which has been made for establishing a Loan Office; though a Scheme of this Sort had, with Success, been adopted by another Colony. It is, with much Unwillingness, that I intermeddle with the Concerns of others, but your Author has made it necessary. From Dr. Douglass's Summary of the Proceedings of the New England Colonies we learn that there had been emitted in Paper Money to the enormous Amount of about three Million seven hundred and forty eight Thousand Pounds, of which Sum the Proportion of the Massachusetts's Bay alone was 2,466,712l. These Sums he tells us were partly intended to defray the Expences of some Expeditions they were engaged in, partly to defray the Expence of Government and that a considerable Proportion was lent out to the Inhabitants upon Mortgages to Government at a long Period: Whether proper and adequate Funds were established for the Redemption of this Money, I will not determine, though I should suppose the contrary, because, from the Author's Account, after deducting 2,342,390l. reimbursed by Parliament to those Colonies for their Expences in the Reduction of Louisbourg, there remained a Debt of about 1,405,000l. New England Currency: The Doctor farther tells us that, in the Year 1748, their Exchange had risen ten for one, that is 100l. of their Currency would purchase no more than 100l. Sterling. The vast Unlikeness of their Situation to ours I shall leave to the Candour of your Readers, without any farther Comment. Whether the British Parliament did right in interposing in an Instance even of this extraordinary Nature, is a political Question that would require a different Discussion. It is asserted that our Emissions of Paper Money have banished Gold and Silver, by which, I suppose, the Author means, if we had no Paper, the Place of it would have been supplied by the precious Metals; if so, the Quantity of Money in the Country would have been nearly equal, and I would fain know whether Gold and Silver are not as likely to contribute to the Extravagance of our Inhabitants, as Paper. But perhaps his Observation alludes to the Superabundance, of Paper we once had, which I have acknowledged might have been a necessary Evil; but this will also prove that our Commodities rose in Price, as few could be passed of the Paper Money without giving Value for it.
I have said thus much, in Hopes of removing any Prejudices that may have been imbibed from general Principles. I am not and never was an Advocate for Paper Money, except in Cases of absolute Necessity, and it is my earnest Wish that no unhappy Incident may ever revive an Occasion of our engaging in it hereafter. The present Object of my Concern is to support the Credit of what we have left and I must own it gives me Pain to see any Thing done, however undesignedly, that has a Tendency to depreciate it. If a Doubt remains with any one as to the Sufficiency of the Security, which the Holders of our Paper have for its Redemption, I flatter myself that I can, with great Ease, give the utmost Satisfaction upon this Head.
As to the Confusion of the Funds complained of, in this the Author is much mistaken. The Funds are entirely distinct and the Balance due on each may be seen to a Shilling. It hath, in the Letter to my Correspondent in London, been acknowledged, that, from there being in Circulation Notes of different Emissions, which was occasioned by former Mismanagements, and because the Payments made into the Treasury were indiscriminately in such Notes, as the Collectors could receive, that one Fund has become indebted to another; but this makes no Difference as to the Quantity of Money in Circulation. If, for Example and to speak in round, easy Numbers, there were in Circulation one Hundred Pounds, one Half of the Notes issued in 1762, and the other of those issued in 1769; a Collector ought in Strictness to pay into the Treasury fifty Pounds for the Taxes of 1769 in those Notes; but instead of this, he receives of the People and pays fifty Pounds in the Notes of 1762; so much is sunk and there remains only fifty Pounds out. If a Person is satisfied with the Security given by the Publick for both Sorts of Money, what Difference can it make to him whether he is possessed of a genuine Note of 1762 or 1769? And this is all the mighty Confusion. That it doth not consist with strict Propriety to suffer Paper Money to continue in Circulation after the Period of its Redemption is past, must be acknowledged; but how could this have been avoided, after what happened, without obliging the People to pay new Taxes? This indeed ought and I am persuaded would have been done, if there had been any apparent Necessity for it; but the former Funds, after the strictest Examination, were judged amply sufficient to redeem all the Notes outstanding, and the Money was in such good Credit, that it was generally preferred either to Gold or Silver. I have acknowledged that so large a Quantity of Paper Money, as we had formerly in Circulation, might have contributed to raise Exchange. and it is supposed by some that what still remains produces the same bad Effect, and moreover banishes Gold and Silver, to the great Prejudice of the Country; as a Proof of this the late Exports of Specie, I suppose will be appealed to. Whether the Exporters, in general will find their Account in sending the Money to England, rather than give thirty per Cent. for Bills, I will not say, but I have seen a Calculation made by a Gentleman of some Gold exported last May, of which he has just received an Account, by which it appears he has lost nearly two and a Half per Cent. I will readily grant that, in a Country possessed of no other Money than Gold and Silver, Exchange cannot rise above a certain Point, but then, there ought to be enough of this Money to answer both the Purposes of Remittances to other Countries, and to serve as a Medium of Traffick at home. Whoever supposes that we might have had Gold and Silver enough for each Occasion must be a Stranger to the many Complaints, which prevail of the great Scarcity of them in most Countries, with which we are connected. Some I know are sanguine enough to think that our Commodities would have brought in Gold and Silver; but this, I am persuaded, would have been in such small Quantities, that, if the Produce of our Estates could have been sold for no other Sort of Money, they would either have remained, as Drugs upon our Hands, or we must have parted with them at such miserable low Prices, as no Man could live by, and such, as hardly any Variation of Exchange, considering the complicated internal Affairs of this Country, could have compensated for. I am apt to think that some have not fully considered how very necessary a sufficient Quantity of Money is in every Community to transact their internal Affairs, to promote Industry and employ the Inhabitants of every Class to Advantage; let them consult the Police of the best regulated and most thrifty Countries in the World and they may be thoroughly informed; but, if they should not be satisfied from thence, let them exercise a little Patience, till our Paper Money is quite gone, and then, without pretending to the Gift of Prophecy, I will venture to believe that they will feel the Loss of it.
As to Exchange, if we take a View of it with the principal combined Causes, by which it is influenced, how strangely shall we find some Gentlemen mistaken in ascribing its Rise chiefly, if not solely to Paper Money? Having, for many Years, been pretty attentive to the Fluctuations of this merchantable Commodity, for so I must take the Liberty of calling it on this Occasion, I am not quite unprepared to form a tolerable Judgment of it. From April 1751 to April 1755 inclusive, Exchange fluctuated from twenty seven and a Half to thirty per Cent. though it was generally at thirty, and in October 1752 it was as high as thirty two per Cent. Paper Money was not known in this Country at either of these Periods; and I would gladly know how it happened that it rose so much above, what is called Par. I will not attempt to avail myself of the forty five per Cent. Difference, which prevailed in the War before last, because a very high Insurance might have had great Influence; but the Instances mentioned happened in Times of profound Peace. I will suppose that we have now in Circulation about 50,000l. though the real Sum I am very confident is less; the Exchange, so much complained of, is at thirty per Cent. In the Year 1766, when there were above 200,000l. of Notes in Circulation, Exchange was at twenty five per Cent. and some
Years ago, when the Paper in Circulation amounted to 140,000l. Exchange was down as low as fifteen per Cent; in May 1771 it was at twenty per Cent. and continued at the same Rate in October, though the 60,000l. was then issued to pay for lost Tobacco. To what could all these Shiftings and Changes have been owing? To nothing more or less than certain Causes, which are well understood in the commercial World. Bills of Exchange considered as a Merchandise, in Respect to Price, should be viewed in a compound Proportion, directly as to the Demand, and reciprocally as to the Plenty of them; or, in other Words, the Value or Price of Bills will be in Proportion to the Number of them brought to Market, compared with the Quantity of Money, which may be there to purchase them; if more Money, than Bills, Exchange will rise; if less Money, than the Drawers have Occasion for, Exchange will fall. A few Years since, Bills were so plenty at Market that the Drawers could hardly procure Money enough at fifteen per Cent. and lately, they have become so scarce, that it is doubted by some whether the monied Men could have made all their Remittances even at an higher Exchange, than prevailed, had they not exported a Quantity of Specie. The former very low Exchange brought in great Part of the Specie, we had in the Country; this, added to what Money was here before, contributed to raise Exchange; but the great governing Cause of this Rise was the extreme Scarcity of Bills, and this, owing chiefly to Misfortunes in Great Britain. At the same Time the Demands for them appeared greatly increased, probably owing to the vast Importations of Goods for several Years, which must have augmented the Balance of Trade greatly against us. From this Source, in my Opinion, are derived the greatest Misfortunes to this Country. Could we but prevail with ourselves to lessen our Imports, and endeavour to make, within ourselves, such Necessaries, as our Soil and Climate are well adapted to, the Balance would soon be changed in our Favour and we need not fear any ill Consequences attending Exchange, though the Quantity of Paper Money should be much greater than it is.
I would observe farther that, though our Paper Money is by some few so much complained of, I do not recollect one single Instance of a Drawer's receiving a Shilling more in Paper for his Bills, than he did in Gold or Silver.
That our Paper Currency hath hitherto supported its Credit so well could not, as is supposed, have been owing barely to what the Virginian is pleased to term the “Countenance of the Legislature,” nor to “Want of Thought in the Possessors of it,” nor to “the Absence of other Money.” I rather presume that those, who have had most to do with it, were Men versed in Business, particularly well acquainted with Money Matters and who were satisfied that this Money was established by the Laws of the Community on proper Principles. It was not owing to “the Absence of other Money,” because for many Years and till Exchange lately took a little Start, the Paper Money was generally preferred to Gold or Silver, and I believe, at this Time, it is preferred to all Kinds of Silver, except Dollars, which happen to be in Demand in Great Britain, and this, even under the supposed Disadvantage of its not being a legal Tender, which surely must be considered by every impartial Person as a Proof of its Goodness.
Who the Gentleman was of such “Affluence and Credit in England and yet terrified with Apprehensions of a Jail, because his Creditor insisted on receiving Gold or Silver and would not take the Paper he was possessed of,” I do not know, though I must suppose his Affluence and Credit would have secured him against these terrible Apprehensions, had he inclined to have made Use of either. He possibly might have applied to the Treasury, though I do not recollect an Instance of a Person's appearing under these Circumstances; if the Sum was large, it is probable it was not in the Treasurer's Power, at the Time, to accommodate him, otherwise he certainly would have done it.
The true State of the Treasury, in Respect to Gold and Silver (for there are no Secrets, which I would wish to conceal) has been this. In the Course of Business there had circulated through the Office very considerable Sums of cash and the Treasury for several Years was actually possessed of this Kind of Money from fifteen to twenty Thousand Pounds, which remained ready to be exchanged for Paper. The Holders of the Notes, especially such as were tattered or torn, were repeatedly invited to bring them in. The Treasurer frequently made personal Applications, just before the Meetings of the Committee appointed to burn the Notes, to such Persons as he supposed possessed of any Quantity of the Money and desired them to exchange it, that the Burnings might be as large as he could make them. Notwithstanding this, the Holders of the Notes, many at least, declined bringing them in, generally giving for Reasons that they were satisfied with the Paper and that it was most convenient. When Exchange about July 1772 rose to twenty five per Cent. the monied Men having been accustomed to buy Bills under Par, hearing that Exchange was low to the Northward, and, in Hopes of giving a Check to it there! made considerable Draughts on the Treasury and continued to do so until the Stock of Specie was nearly exhausted; so that the Treasurer hath not, of late, been able to furnish any large Sums of Gold and Silver; he hath endeavoured to reserve as much as would accommodate those, who might have Occasion of small Change and to take in the tattered Notes.
Under these Circumstances, it must be submitted how friendly it is to this Community, in any Member of it, who happens to be averse to our Currency, to seize an unfortunate Moment, and from a Disappointment of one or two Individuals, to conclude that our Money is of little or no Worth, and this, though a whole Country stands bound as Security for it. I should rather have expected, as is done in other Countries, since every Man is certainly interested in supporting the Credit of the Money, that every Virginian, at least, would have taken Pains and Pleasure in assisting the Treasury, by throwing into it all the Specie he could.
Your Correspondent declines investigating thoroughly “whether the late Act of Assembly authorising the Emission of 36,834l. was founded either on Wisdom or Necessity;” he might have had his Reasons for declining this Investigation, and therefore, instead of untying the Knot, he, Alexander like, cuts it by giving us his Opinion, as “an Individual,” that it rested on neither. I will not venture to rest a Matter of such Consequence upon my private Opinion, but rather choose to rely on the better Judgment of the Legislature, which I know corresponded with the previous Desires and Wishes of the Generality of the Trade, that both the Emissions of 1769 and 1771 should be immediately called in; if a better Expedient, than that made Use of, had been proposed, it doubtless would have been adopted. But I have lived long enough to know how much easier it is to find Fault with Measures, than to amend them.
The Necessity, without repeating all the Reasons formerly mentioned, was evident from this single Consideration, that the Circulation of the Notes of both Emissions was stopped through the greatest Part, if not the whole Country. Could “Justice, Policy, or common Humanity” have justified the Legislature in withholding the best Relief from the Owners of these Notes, that it was in their Power to give them? But we are told that “the new Money was not a Whit less liable to Abuse than the Emissions of 1769 and 1771, although it was certain that the new Emission must give Rise to a considerable publick Expence.”
Publick Expences I know are terrible Bugbears to some People, who, though daily Experience shows that even private Families cannot live free of considerable Expences seem to suppose that the Business of this great Country and every Contingency may be supported almost without them; but, for my Part, I shall never grudge a moderate publick Expence to secure either a great publick Good or to relieve the Community from a great publick Calamity. If any one doubts my Disposition to political Economy, or my Endeavours to save every Thing to the Country, that is in my Power, I shall only say that I have been peculiarly unfortunate, in not being able to convince him or both, and, perhaps, I may not live to see better Opportunities of doing it, than have already offered.
That the new Money may be liable to Abuse, I will not deny; but, that it is much more secure against Counterfeits and Forgeries, than any we have ever had, is submitted to the Judgments of all, who have examined it. This was the Opinion of the Assembly, even of those Members I conversed with, who were against the Emission. The Means of discovering the good from the forged Bills of the other Emissions having been made publick, would have rendered them, after a Time, the more dangerous. The Forgers were possessed of exact Copies of the original Arms, Types and all the other Devices; the chief Errors of the Counterfeits consisted in the Difference of Paper and the Water Letters; if these had been corrected, it might have puzzled the most knowing to detect the new Forgeries; tho' we could have been sure that no new Counterfeits would have been attempted, yet how many People in the Country are unable to understand these discriminating Marks, which are now become familiar to Persons of Discernment? Can any unprejudiced Person, after a Moment's Reflection, say it is within any Degree of Comparison, near so easy to forge an entire Set of new Bills, impressed on Paper of a new Fabrick, guarded in the Manner these are, as it is to correct the Errors in the Forgeries of the former Notes?
“No good Reason, it seems, has yet been furnished for empowering the Emission of so large a Sum as 36,834l.” considering the Sums, that the Taxes had brought in, as the Treasurer informed the Publick. Is it not surprisingly strange that the Author should insist that so large a Sum was ordered to be emitted, when it was clearly proved by the Letter he quotes and the Act of Assembly thereby referred to, that no more than 25,000l. could be issued? The Sum, however, was not so much relied on, as that the Assembly had not taken upon them to direct other Notes to be issued to call in those of 1769, whose Period of Redemption was past, and that the Notes to be issued for calling in those of 1771 were only to be substituted in their Stead and made redeemable on the same Day that they were to be redeemed. Whether receiving old Notes for Taxes, instead of new ones, under the Circumstances formerly related, was proper or not, is again submitted; it was unavoidable, and the Country could not have sustained the least possible Inconvenience, had not the new Notes been unhappily forged, which I believe no one foresaw or could have suspected. One Expence indeed will be incurred by it; I mean the Interest to be paid on such Sums, as have been borrowed to redeem the Notes of 1769, but this, and all the Expences attending the new Money, will be fully reimbursed by the Interest received on the Balance due from the late Treasurer's Estate.
What Principles the Author had to go upon in estimating the Losses incurred by the late Forgeries, he best knows; but, from all I have been able to collect, I have my Hopes that they do not amount to one fourth Part of the Sum. Be this however more or less, it is much to be lamented; and the Cautions suggested by it I am hopeful will prove the Means of preventing such Mischiefs hereafter. Could those, who have the greatest Dislike to Paper Money, prevail with themselves to exercise a little Patience, this Business, in a few Years, will probably be all wound up and settled to the Satisfaction of every one.
I should do Injustice to the Conclusion of the Address, if I suffered it to pass unnoticed. In Answer to a Quotation from Baron Montesquieu, I beg Leave to refer your Author to Baron Pufendorf (from whom, by the Bye, Montesquieu borrowed his Sentiments) where he will find that this learned Author considers every Kind of Money as variable in its Value. “When therefore, says he, the Price of a Thing happens to be changed, we must carefully distinguish whether that Change be made in the Value of the Thing or in the Value of Money. The former happens, when the Plenty of Money, standing as it was, the Commodity begins to be more plentiful or scarce than usual; the latter, when the Commodity, remaining as usual, the Plenty of Money is increased or decreased;” which Observations are illustrated by familiar Examples.
Thus you may see, Gentlemen, that a Man possessed to-day of 120l. in Gold and Silver which would entitle him to 100l. Sterling, to-morrow, by such an Influx of these precious Metals as seems to be wished and expected, might be obliged to give 120l. for 100l. Sterling. Or, if the Number of Bills brought to Market should be considerably lessened, though the Quantity of Gold and Silver continued as formerly, he might feel the same Effects. The Gentleman speaks of an “Irruption of thirty or forty Thousand Pounds from our Printing Office” just as an Historian would describe the Irruption of the Goths and Vandals; but surely he would not insinuate that nothing more hath been thought necessary, than barely sending an Order to the Printer to strike off such a Number of Treasury Notes, as if they were no more than so many simple Advertisements, he must know that there never has been an Emission voted, but upon the maturest Deliberation and then only, on the most pressing Emergency; he must also acknowledge that, in every Instance, the most competent Funds have been established for the Redemption of the Money.
Fearing that I may have trespassed too far on your Indulgence, I shall only add that I am, Gentlemen, your obliged humble Servant,
RO.C.NICHOLAS.
What sub-type of article is it?
What themes does it touch?
What keywords are associated?
What entities or persons were involved?
Letter to Editor Details
Author
Ro. C. Nicholas (Robert Carter Nicholas)
Recipient
Mess. Purdie & Dixon (The Printers)
Main Argument
Defends Virginia's paper currency against 'A Virginian's' critique: the wartime emissions were a necessary resource, their funds were adequate, losses were overstated, and exchange rates were driven mainly by trade balance and scarcity of bills, not by paper money itself.
Notable Details
- quotes Pufendorf on the variable value of money
- cites Dr. Douglass on New England emissions
- detailed treasury account of gold and silver exchanges
- addresses the 36,834l emission and counterfeiting concerns