Thanks for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free today to connect your AI tools to the Library of Congress' newspaper collection.

Try it free
Page 3 of Edwardsville Spectator, with this article outlined

Edwardsville Spectator Domestic News May 29, 1819

Edwardsville, Madison, Illinois

What is this article about?

Controversy between Generals Jackson and Scott over an anonymous letter about Jackson's 1817 order; Scott attributes it to De Witt Clinton, who denies it publicly.

Quality green show the numbers
Measured from the scan — how cleanly the OCR engine read the characters
Mean ink quality
99.0% The length-weighted average confidence across the OCR lines — the mean of exactly the per-line scores whose tails the two figures below report. Typical is 99%.
Illegible ink
0.0% Text sitting in OCR-detected lines that scored below 80% confidence — very shaky reads. Weighted by line length, so one long bad line counts for more than a short one.
Uncertain ink
0.8% Text in lines that scored 80–90% — somewhat shaky reads.
Matches source
99.26% How closely the served text matches the raw OCR of the same boxes, letter by letter, after collapsing spacing and case. This measures agreement, not correctness: the OCR is often wrong and the extractor corrects it, so 100% does not mean perfect, and a low figure usually means poor scan text was rewritten rather than that text was lost (length vs source shows loss).
Length vs source
99.13% Below 100% means text was dropped from the OCR; above means text was added to make it read.
Assembled by the extraction model — whether the stitched-together text holds up; catches layout and segmentation errors, which the scores above cannot see
Transcription confidence
96.0% (typical 96%) How cleanly the extractor could assemble what it was given. Low here with clean ink scores points at layout analysis — the characters were read correctly but grouped or ordered wrongly.
Comprehension
95.0% Whether the piece reads coherently start to finish. Can stay high while transcription confidence drops, when only part of the component is affected.

Clipping

Full Text

FROM THE FRANKFORT ARGUS.

JACKSON, SCOTT AND CLINTON.

All our readers probably remember the famous general order of general Jackson, issued in 1817, commanding his subordinate officers not to obey any orders from the war department, unless they were sent through the commander in chief.

It seems that general Scott, then in New-York, condemned the order, and declared it little less than an act of mutiny.

Some listener communicated the substance of Scott's remarks to Jackson in the following anonymous letter:

Anonymous letter addressed to Major General Andrew Jackson, postmarked “New-York, August 14,” and received the 31st Sept. 1817.

“Your late order has been the subject of much private, and some public remark. The war office gentry and their adherents, pensioners and expectants, have all been busy; but no one (of sufficient mark for your notice) more than Major General Scott, who, I am credibly informed, goes so far as to call the order in question an act of mutiny. In this district he is the organ of government insinuations, and the supposed author of the paper inclosed—which, however, (the better to cover him) was not published until he had left this city for the lakes. Be on your guard, as they have placed spies upon Brown here—so it is probable you are not without them. The eastern federalists having now all become good republicans, and pledged to support the President, as he to them, government can now do very well without the aid of Tenn. &c. A word to the wise is enough. The enclosed is taken from the Columbian, a paper of much circulation in this state, New-York.”

General Jackson enclosed a copy of this letter to Scott, inquiring whether he had made the remarks alluded to. The controversy ended in an abusive personal contest between the two generals.

General Scott has lately published a pamphlet containing the whole correspondence. In this pamphlet he gives his belief that De Witt Clinton was the author of the anonymous letter. In reply to this charge De Witt Clinton has addressed to the public the following letter, which contains as much severity as could well be crowded into so small a compass.

From the Albany Gazette, April 8.

TO THE PUBLIC.

General Scott, of the army of the U. States, having in a letter of the 2d January, 1818, to general Jackson, insinuated that I had written, dictated, or instigated an anonymous letter to the latter gentleman from unworthy motives, and for improper purposes; and having also concealed this imputation from me, until the publication of a pamphlet which reached me on the 4th inst. I have considered it proper to declare, that I have had no agency or participation in writing, dictating or instigating any anonymous letter whatever to gen. Jackson. That I am entirely ignorant of the author—and that the intimation of general Scott is totally and unqualifiedly false, to all intents and in all respects. This declaration is made from motives of respect for public opinion, and not from any regard for general Scott, whose conduct on this occasion, is such a total departure from honor and propriety as to render him unworthy of the notice of a man who has any respect for himself.

It is not probable that I can at this time have any recollection of having had the honor of seeing general Scott, on the 9th of June, 1817, at a dinner in New-York, or of the topics of conversation as he suggests; circumstances so unimportant are not apt to be impressed on the memory. But I feel a confident persuasion, that I did not make use of any expression incompatible with the high respect which I entertain for gen. Jackson.

DE WITT CLINTON.

Albany, 6th April, 1819.

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics Military

What keywords are associated?

Jackson Scott Controversy De Witt Clinton Anonymous Letter General Order 1817 Mutiny

What entities or persons were involved?

Andrew Jackson Winfield Scott De Witt Clinton

Where did it happen?

New York

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

New York

Event Date

April 1819

Key Persons

Andrew Jackson Winfield Scott De Witt Clinton

Outcome

controversy leads to public letters and denials

Are you sure?