Thanks for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free today to connect your AI tools to the Library of Congress' newspaper collection.

Try it free
Page 3 of Edwardsville Spectator, with this article outlined

Edwardsville Spectator Letter to Editor October 9, 1819

Edwardsville, Madison, Illinois

What is this article about?

A farmer from Madison County, Illinois, writes to oppose petitioning the governor to call another extra session of the legislature, arguing the current legislature's laws are unconstitutional and oppressive and that the people should wait for the next election to correct abuses.

Quality green show the numbers
Measured from the scan — how cleanly the OCR engine read the characters
Mean ink quality
99.0% The length-weighted average confidence across the OCR lines — the mean of exactly the per-line scores whose tails the two figures below report. Typical is 99%.
Illegible ink
0.0% Text sitting in OCR-detected lines that scored below 80% confidence — very shaky reads. Weighted by line length, so one long bad line counts for more than a short one.
Uncertain ink
0.0% Text in lines that scored 80–90% — somewhat shaky reads.
Matches source
99.4% How closely the served text matches the raw OCR of the same boxes, letter by letter, after collapsing spacing and case. This measures agreement, not correctness: the OCR is often wrong and the extractor corrects it, so 100% does not mean perfect, and a low figure usually means poor scan text was rewritten rather than that text was lost (length vs source shows loss).
Length vs source
98.96% Below 100% means text was dropped from the OCR; above means text was added to make it read.
Assembled by the extraction model — whether the stitched-together text holds up; catches layout and segmentation errors, which the scores above cannot see
Transcription confidence
95.0% (typical 96%) How cleanly the extractor could assemble what it was given. Low here with clean ink scores points at layout analysis — the characters were read correctly but grouped or ordered wrongly.
Comprehension
95.0% Whether the piece reads coherently start to finish. Can stay high while transcription confidence drops, when only part of the component is affected.

Clipping

Full Text

FOR THE SPECTATOR

Mr. PRINTER,

I am sorry to learn from the Shawneetown paper that it is proposed to petition the governor to call another extra meeting of the legislature. The reasons given for that measure are the very reasons which induce me to oppose it. The unconstitutional, oppressive, anti-republican, unequal, and ridiculous laws of the last session, induce me to hope that their authors may never have an opportunity to do us any more mischief. That the people will never give them this opportunity, I am fully convinced. And it is hoped that his excellency the governor will not, without the most urgent necessity, put it in the power of the present legislature, to add to the long catalogue of injuries which they have heaped upon their constituents.

If, as the Shawneetown paper says, there is not money enough in the state to pay the taxes, the consequence will be that a great deal of property will be offered by the sheriffs at public sale, for the taxes upon it. The tax law being manifestly and palpably unconstitutional, very few will probably bid for lands sold under that law; and they will, therefore, be struck off to the state. Next year the people will elect another legislature, who will be selected with the express view of rectifying the abuses committed by the present general assembly. And the lands struck off to the state, will, most probably, upon the payment of an equitable and constitutional tax, be restored to their former possessors.

Every one must, I think, be convinced that the present legislature are totally incompetent to discharge the important duties assigned to them. Still, however, they set as high a value upon their time and services, as the most accomplished legislators. Should the governor again call them together, they would probably spin out another long session without producing any benefit to the community, unless the payment of four dollars a day to each member, is considered a public benefit. Had "our sage convention" thought fit to allow us the privilege of electing our representatives annually, we might now have an opportunity to correct the errors of the present legislature; but, situated as we are, I can see no better way than to bear, with as much fortitude as we can, the evils under which we suffer, until the period arrives when our ballots at the polls can afford an effectual remedy.

Again.—The people have had no opportunity of knowing, to any considerable extent, what has been already done by the present legislature; for the laws and journals, if printed, have not yet been distributed.* Should the legislature again be called together, and should they make no better provision for the publication of their acts than they did at their last session, we should remain another year in ignorance as to what are the laws of the land. But next August the people can elect a capable legislature; and the governor, if he thinks proper, can convene them immediately after their election; and they can repeal the unjust and unconstitutional laws of the present legislature, and substitute good laws in their stead, which laws can be immediately published.

But should his excellency the governor think proper to call another extra meeting of the present legislature, it is hoped that he will previously issue writs of election to fill the vacancies occasioned by the appointment of five members of the legislature to the office of commissioners for locating the seat of government. Should his excellency entertain any doubts on this subject, I beg leave to refer him to the 25th section of the 2d article of our constitution, which provides that no person holding any lucrative office under this state shall have a seat in the general assembly.

A FARMER.
Madison county, Oct. 5, 1819.

* Since the above was written, I have learned that the laws of the last session have just been received in this county. It is confidently believed that the journals will also be published before the first Monday in August next.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Political

What themes does it touch?

Politics Constitutional Rights Taxation

What keywords are associated?

Extra Legislative Session Opposition Unconstitutional Tax Law Illinois Legislature 1819 Constitutional Rights Election Remedy

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Printer A Farmer

Letter to Editor Details

Author

A Farmer

Recipient

Mr. Printer

Main Argument

Opposes calling another extra session of the legislature, arguing the current legislature is incompetent and its laws unconstitutional; prefers waiting for the next election to remedy abuses.

Notable Details

  • mentions the tax law as manifestly unconstitutional
  • notes the legislature's pay of four dollars a day per member
  • cites the 25th section of the 2d article of the constitution barring holders of lucrative office from the assembly
  • notes five members appointed as commissioners for locating the seat of government

Are you sure?