Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Fowle's New Hampshire Gazette And General Advertiser Literary March 18, 1785
Portsmouth, Rockingham, New Hampshire
What is this article about?
A posthumous prose essay by Mr. Butler on faith, reason, and religion, arguing that faith is below ignorance, warning against too-curious religious inquiry, and praising charity as the chief Christian virtue that outlasts faith and hope.
Quality green show the numbers
Measured from the scan
— how cleanly the OCR engine read the characters
- Mean ink quality
- 99.0% The length-weighted average confidence across the OCR lines — the mean of exactly the per-line scores whose tails the two figures below report. Typical is 99%.
- Illegible ink
- 0.0% Text sitting in OCR-detected lines that scored below 80% confidence — very shaky reads. Weighted by line length, so one long bad line counts for more than a short one.
- Uncertain ink
- 1.1% Text in lines that scored 80–90% — somewhat shaky reads.
- Matches source
- 95.75% How closely the served text matches the raw OCR of the same boxes, letter by letter, after collapsing spacing and case. This measures agreement, not correctness: the OCR is often wrong and the extractor corrects it, so 100% does not mean perfect, and a low figure usually means poor scan text was rewritten rather than that text was lost (length vs source shows loss).
- Length vs source
- 98.96% Below 100% means text was dropped from the OCR; above means text was added to make it read.
Assembled by the extraction model
— whether the stitched-together text holds up; catches layout and segmentation errors, which the scores above cannot see
- Transcription confidence
- 93.0% (typical 96%) How cleanly the extractor could assemble what it was given. Low here with clean ink scores points at layout analysis — the characters were read correctly but grouped or ordered wrongly.
- Comprehension
- 95.0% Whether the piece reads coherently start to finish. Can stay high while transcription confidence drops, when only part of the component is affected.
Full Text
Mr. Butler's Posthumous Works.
FAITH is so far from being above reason and knowledge, that it is below ignorance, which it depends upon: For no man can believe and not be ignorant; but he may be ignorant and not believe.—Whensoever reason and demonstration appear; faith and ignorance vanish together.
They that dispute matters of faith into nice particulars, and curious circumstances do as unwisely as a geographer, that would undertake to draw a true map of terra incognita, by mere imagination. For though there is such a part of the earth, and that not without mountains and vallies, and plains, and rivers; yet to attempt the description of these, and assign their situations and tracts, without a view of the place, is more than ridiculous.
He that thinks to please God, by forcing his understanding in disquisitions of him, beyond the limits which he has been pleased to prescribe, beside the loss of his labour, does but endeavour to intrude where he is denied access, and preposterously attempts to serve God by disobeying him.
It is a dangerous thing to be too inquisitive, and to search too narrowly into a true religion: For 50,000 Bethshemites were destroyed, for looking into the Ark of the Covenant; and ten times as many have been ruined, for looking too curiously into that book, in which that story is recorded.
Almost all the miracles in the Jewish history, from their deliverance from their first slavery, by the plagues of Egypt, to their second captivity in Babylon, were performed by the destruction, ruin, and calamity of mankind.—But all those that our Saviour wrought to confirm his doctrine, quite contrary, by raising the dead to life, curing of desperate diseases, making the blind see, casting out of devils, and feeding of hungry multitudes, &c. but never doing harm to any thing; all suitable to those excellent lessons of peace, love, charity, and concord, to which the whole purpose of all that he did or said perpetually tended.—Whosoever, therefore, does endeavour to draw rules, or examples, for the practice of Christianity, from the extraordinary proceedings of the Jews, must of necessity make a strange confusion and adulterate mixture of the Christian religion, by depraving and alloying it with that, which is so directly adverse and contrary to its own nature. And as this unnatural mixture, of two different religions, was the first cause of dissention among the Apostles, and afterwards determined and resolved against, by them all: So there is no doctrine of rebellion, that was ever vented among Christians, that was not revived, and raised, from this kind of false and forced construction.
The enmities of religious people would never rise to such a height, were it not for their mistake, that God is better served with their opinions than their practices; opinions being very inconsiderable, further than they have influence upon actions.
All reformations of religions, seldom extend further than the mere opinions of men. The amendment of their lives and conversations, are equally unregarded by all churches, how much soever they differ in doctrine and discipline. And though all the reformation our Saviour preached to the world, was only repentance and amendment of life, without taking any notice at all of men's opinions and judgments; yet all the Christian churches take the contrary course, and believe religion more concerned in one erroneous opinion, than all the most inhuman and impious actions in the world.
Charity is the chiefest of all Christian virtues, without which, all the rest signify nothing: For faith and hope can only bring us on our way to the confines of this world; but charity is not only our convoy to heaven, but engaged to stay with us there for ever.—And yet there is not any sort of religious people in the world, that will not renounce and disclaim this necessary cause of salvation for mere trifles of the slightest moment imaginable; nay, will not preposterously endeavour to secure their eternal happiness by destroying that, without which it is never to be obtained. From hence are all their spiritual quarrels derived, and such punctilios of opinion, though more nice and peevish than those of love and honour in romances, are yet maintained with such animosity, as if heaven were to be purchased no way but that, which is the most certain and infallible, of all others, to lose it.
FAITH is so far from being above reason and knowledge, that it is below ignorance, which it depends upon: For no man can believe and not be ignorant; but he may be ignorant and not believe.—Whensoever reason and demonstration appear; faith and ignorance vanish together.
They that dispute matters of faith into nice particulars, and curious circumstances do as unwisely as a geographer, that would undertake to draw a true map of terra incognita, by mere imagination. For though there is such a part of the earth, and that not without mountains and vallies, and plains, and rivers; yet to attempt the description of these, and assign their situations and tracts, without a view of the place, is more than ridiculous.
He that thinks to please God, by forcing his understanding in disquisitions of him, beyond the limits which he has been pleased to prescribe, beside the loss of his labour, does but endeavour to intrude where he is denied access, and preposterously attempts to serve God by disobeying him.
It is a dangerous thing to be too inquisitive, and to search too narrowly into a true religion: For 50,000 Bethshemites were destroyed, for looking into the Ark of the Covenant; and ten times as many have been ruined, for looking too curiously into that book, in which that story is recorded.
Almost all the miracles in the Jewish history, from their deliverance from their first slavery, by the plagues of Egypt, to their second captivity in Babylon, were performed by the destruction, ruin, and calamity of mankind.—But all those that our Saviour wrought to confirm his doctrine, quite contrary, by raising the dead to life, curing of desperate diseases, making the blind see, casting out of devils, and feeding of hungry multitudes, &c. but never doing harm to any thing; all suitable to those excellent lessons of peace, love, charity, and concord, to which the whole purpose of all that he did or said perpetually tended.—Whosoever, therefore, does endeavour to draw rules, or examples, for the practice of Christianity, from the extraordinary proceedings of the Jews, must of necessity make a strange confusion and adulterate mixture of the Christian religion, by depraving and alloying it with that, which is so directly adverse and contrary to its own nature. And as this unnatural mixture, of two different religions, was the first cause of dissention among the Apostles, and afterwards determined and resolved against, by them all: So there is no doctrine of rebellion, that was ever vented among Christians, that was not revived, and raised, from this kind of false and forced construction.
The enmities of religious people would never rise to such a height, were it not for their mistake, that God is better served with their opinions than their practices; opinions being very inconsiderable, further than they have influence upon actions.
All reformations of religions, seldom extend further than the mere opinions of men. The amendment of their lives and conversations, are equally unregarded by all churches, how much soever they differ in doctrine and discipline. And though all the reformation our Saviour preached to the world, was only repentance and amendment of life, without taking any notice at all of men's opinions and judgments; yet all the Christian churches take the contrary course, and believe religion more concerned in one erroneous opinion, than all the most inhuman and impious actions in the world.
Charity is the chiefest of all Christian virtues, without which, all the rest signify nothing: For faith and hope can only bring us on our way to the confines of this world; but charity is not only our convoy to heaven, but engaged to stay with us there for ever.—And yet there is not any sort of religious people in the world, that will not renounce and disclaim this necessary cause of salvation for mere trifles of the slightest moment imaginable; nay, will not preposterously endeavour to secure their eternal happiness by destroying that, without which it is never to be obtained. From hence are all their spiritual quarrels derived, and such punctilios of opinion, though more nice and peevish than those of love and honour in romances, are yet maintained with such animosity, as if heaven were to be purchased no way but that, which is the most certain and infallible, of all others, to lose it.
What sub-type of article is it?
Essay
What themes does it touch?
Religious
Moral Virtue
What keywords are associated?
Faith
Reason
Charity
Religious Reflection
Christian Virtue
What entities or persons were involved?
Mr. Butler
Literary Details
Title
Mr. Butler's Posthumous Works.
Author
Mr. Butler
Subject
Reflections On Faith, Reason, Religious Controversy, And Charity
Form / Style
Aphoristic Prose Essay In Short Paragraphs
Key Lines
Faith Is So Far From Being Above Reason And Knowledge, That It Is Below Ignorance, Which It Depends Upon
Charity Is The Chiefest Of All Christian Virtues, Without Which, All The Rest Signify Nothing