Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Savannah Tribune
Story October 25, 1913

The Savannah Tribune

Savannah, Chatham County, Georgia

What is this article about?

Skeptical report of horticulturist George Snively's claimed success in grafting a tomato stalk onto a potato vine to create a self-reproducing plant near Harrisburg, W. Va., dismissed as unlikely without proof.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

SOUNDS FISHY.

A horticulturist, George Snively, living at Sandy Grove, near Harrisburg, W. Va., is said to have succeeded in grafting a tomato stalk on a potato vine and having the plant reproduce itself, a feat that has never before been accomplished. The facts may be as reported in this case, but they sound decidedly fishy, and it would take ocular proof to convince the average man that the tubers from the potato vine on which this tomato stalk had been grafted would ever produce stalks that would bear tomatoes or that the seed from a tomato produced on the inserted tomato vine would ever develop a root system that would produce a murphy. If a potato blossom were cross fertilized with pollen from a tomato blossom a plant might be developed which would produce both tomatoes and tubers, but the chances seem dead against its ever being accomplished by a process of top grafting.

What sub-type of article is it?

Curiosity Extraordinary Event

What themes does it cover?

Deception

What keywords are associated?

Grafting Tomato Potato Horticulturist Skepticism Reproduction Scientific Feat

What entities or persons were involved?

George Snively

Where did it happen?

Sandy Grove, Near Harrisburg, W. Va.

Story Details

Key Persons

George Snively

Location

Sandy Grove, Near Harrisburg, W. Va.

Story Details

Horticulturist George Snively reportedly succeeded in grafting a tomato stalk onto a potato vine, enabling the plant to reproduce itself, a previously unaccomplished feat. The report expresses strong skepticism, deeming it fishy and requiring ocular proof that tubers would bear tomatoes or tomato seeds would produce potatoes. Suggests cross-fertilization of blossoms as a more plausible method for a dual-producing plant.

Are you sure?