Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
May 18, 1805
Virginia Argus
Richmond, Virginia
What is this article about?
Satirical editorial mocking Federalists for praising Vermont representative Elliot's discernment while abusing President Jefferson, whom Elliot lauds for talents and virtue. Highlights contradiction and accuses Federalists of self-contradiction. Elliot denies changing views, blaming Republicans.
OCR Quality
95%
Excellent
Full Text
The Editor of the 'Pitts' Observatory justly remarks on the absurdity of Federalists in lavishing praises on Elliot's discernment and integrity, and at the same time, pouring out the most violent abuse against the President. How does the case stand? Mr. Elliot, say his Federal panegyrists, has correct views of men and things, & his opinions & assertions are entitled to full credit and confidence. The President, says Mr Elliot, deserves every praise--is a man eminent for talents and patriotism, for distinguished and irreproachable, public and private virtue. The President, aver these champions of Elliot's sense and judgment, is corrupt and unprincipled--stained with every vice and meriting the most hearty execration. Now, if Mr. E. is right, the federalists are wrong. The federalists declare that Mr. E. is correct--and of course, that they themselves are either liars or dupes. Mr E is their own witness--they cannot except to his testimony--and the whole of that testimony is to be taken together.
Elliot, the trimming representative from Vermont, denies that he has changed, and accuses the majority of the republicans with changing. This is like the soldier, who, being reprimanded for being after the rest of the company, declared it was their fault for firing before him.
[Trenton Amer.]
Elliot, the trimming representative from Vermont, denies that he has changed, and accuses the majority of the republicans with changing. This is like the soldier, who, being reprimanded for being after the rest of the company, declared it was their fault for firing before him.
[Trenton Amer.]
What sub-type of article is it?
Partisan Politics
Satire
What keywords are associated?
Federalist Hypocrisy
Elliot Praise
President Criticism
Partisan Contradiction
Vermont Representative
What entities or persons were involved?
Federalists
Mr. Elliot
President
Republicans
Pitts' Observatory
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Federalist Inconsistency In Praising Elliot While Criticizing The President
Stance / Tone
Satirical Critique Of Federalist Hypocrisy
Key Figures
Federalists
Mr. Elliot
President
Republicans
Pitts' Observatory
Key Arguments
Federalists Praise Elliot's Judgment But Contradict His Positive View Of The President
If Elliot Is Correct, Federalists Are Wrong Or Self Deceived
Elliot Denies Personal Change And Blames Republicans
Analogy To Soldier Blaming Others For Firing First