Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Union Daily Times
Story March 23, 1922

The Union Daily Times

Union, Union County, South Carolina

What is this article about?

In Lancaster, the jury in the fraud trial of former Lancaster Mercantile president Charles D. Jones deadlocked after five days, leading to a likely mistrial. Defense alleged conspiracy by competitors; state presented strong evidence.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Lancaster, March 23.— The foreman of the jury in the case of Charles D. Jones, just before 2:30 o'clock this morning, reported to the sheriff that the jury is "hopelessly disagreed," and the sheriff sent for Judge Bowman at his hotel. He was expected to order a mistrial upon arrival at the court house.

Lancaster, March 22.—The case of the state against Charles D. Jones, charged with misappropriation of funds and breach of trust with fraudulent intent from the Lancaster Mercantile company, of which he was former president and manager, was given to the jury this afternoon at 5 o'clock after a trial lasting five days.

Argument was resumed this morning. D. W. Robinson leading off for the state. He was followed by Claud N. Sapp and Thomas F. McDow for the defense, and former Judge Mendel L. Smith closed for the state. An hour each was allowed for argument.

The court room was again jammed, there being 60 women in the audience. The four arguments covered every phase of the case from sarcasm to pathos to facts and evidence. Claud N. Sapp, for defense, made a powerful plea for his client, claiming that a conspiracy had been entered into by Leroy Springs and J. T. Stevens to crush the defendant socially and financially and get rid of him as a business competitor.

The most powerful argument heard in this court in many years was made by Mendel L. Smith for the state. Judge Smith in a speech of one hour and forty minutes went into every point in the case, and the vast crowd listened with rapt attention to his masterly array of the evidence.

Judge Bowman's charge only consumed 20 minutes and most of this was taken up with requests to charge by both sides. The jury immediately after retiring asked that the requests to charge be given them, which was complied with by order of the court. At 7:30 o'clock the jury asked for supper, no agreement having been reached.

Crowds in the court house waited late into the night for the verdict.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Story

What themes does it cover?

Crime Punishment Deception

What keywords are associated?

Fraud Trial Jury Disagreement Mistrial Court Arguments Business Conspiracy

What entities or persons were involved?

Charles D. Jones Judge Bowman D. W. Robinson Claud N. Sapp Thomas F. Mcdow Mendel L. Smith Leroy Springs J. T. Stevens

Where did it happen?

Lancaster

Story Details

Key Persons

Charles D. Jones Judge Bowman D. W. Robinson Claud N. Sapp Thomas F. Mcdow Mendel L. Smith Leroy Springs J. T. Stevens

Location

Lancaster

Event Date

March 22 23

Story Details

The state prosecuted Charles D. Jones for misappropriation of funds and breach of trust from the Lancaster Mercantile company. After five days of trial, arguments were made by both sides, including claims of conspiracy against the defendant. The jury deliberated from 5 p.m. on March 22, requested supper, and by 2:30 a.m. on March 23 reported hopeless disagreement, leading to an expected mistrial ordered by Judge Bowman.

Are you sure?