Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
March 11, 1853
Worcester Daily Spy
Worcester, Worcester County, Massachusetts
What is this article about?
An editorial denounces the unparalleled concentration of legislative, executive, and judicial powers in New York Aldermen, who self-regulate, judge their own laws, and face no effective oversight, citing the New York Tribune.
OCR Quality
95%
Excellent
Full Text
Power Vested in a New York Alderman Man.—As a specimen of the combination of powers in the person of a New York Alderman, a fact unparalleled in any civilized government, we give the following from the New York Tribune of yesterday:
Elected, in many cases by knavery, in his legislative capacity, he makes an ordinance; in his executive capacity (or rather usurpation) he puts it in execution; in his judicial character, he punishes or exculpates, as he may find it for his interest, the breakers of the same enactment. As Supervisor, he selects the Grand Jury that is to investigate his own conduct; as Alderman, he runs the city in debt—as Supervisor, he pays the bill. As Alderman, he enacts laws regulating the sale of liquor; as Commissioner of Excise, he executes the same law; as Judge, he (sometimes) punishes its violation. In fact, the Alderman is everything—lawyer, judge, and executioner;—holding the property, the peace, and honor of the city in his hands, with no effective check upon his conduct, however infamous or dangerous it may be.
Elected, in many cases by knavery, in his legislative capacity, he makes an ordinance; in his executive capacity (or rather usurpation) he puts it in execution; in his judicial character, he punishes or exculpates, as he may find it for his interest, the breakers of the same enactment. As Supervisor, he selects the Grand Jury that is to investigate his own conduct; as Alderman, he runs the city in debt—as Supervisor, he pays the bill. As Alderman, he enacts laws regulating the sale of liquor; as Commissioner of Excise, he executes the same law; as Judge, he (sometimes) punishes its violation. In fact, the Alderman is everything—lawyer, judge, and executioner;—holding the property, the peace, and honor of the city in his hands, with no effective check upon his conduct, however infamous or dangerous it may be.
What sub-type of article is it?
Constitutional
Legal Reform
What keywords are associated?
New York Alderman
Combined Powers
Government Abuse
Unchecked Authority
Liquor Regulation
Grand Jury
City Debt
What entities or persons were involved?
New York Alderman
New York Tribune
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Critique Of Combined Powers In New York Aldermen
Stance / Tone
Strongly Critical Of Unchecked Authority
Key Figures
New York Alderman
New York Tribune
Key Arguments
Aldermen Elected By Knavery Make Ordinances
Aldermen Execute Their Own Ordinances
Aldermen Judge Violations Of Their Ordinances For Personal Interest
Aldermen Select Grand Jury To Investigate Their Conduct
Aldermen Enact Laws Running City In Debt And Then Pay Bills
Aldermen Regulate Liquor Sales, Execute Laws, And Punish Violations
Aldermen Hold All Roles: Lawyer, Judge, Executioner With No Effective Check