Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Virginia Argus
Editorial August 22, 1811

Virginia Argus

Richmond, Virginia

What is this article about?

An anonymous writer from 1776 critiques Federalist hypocrisy in defending British actions like Orders in Council and impressment while condemning French decrees, questioning neutral trade rights and urging avoidance of foreign influences amid tensions with Britain.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

From the Baltimore Whig.

I sometimes read the papers on both sides of the question; and I have at last found out that there is an only American side and a British side to it—say what you please. But, to put it past doubt, I mean to propound two or three questions to the federalists: if they, or any of the Washington society, answer fairly, I will give them credit for being candid for once.

QUESTIONS TO THE FEDERAL PARTY.

What is the reason, that you abuse Bonaparte for rescinding his decrees, as to us; but apologize for England though she keeps her orders in council in force?

How comes it, that you are very angry at Bonaparte for releasing seventeen American vessels; when you don't say one ill word against Britain for condemning eighteen of our ships and cargoes in one day, and the sentence applies to fifty-four, nay to hundreds?

You say England is our very good friend, and has done us no essential injury! If you consider the illegal destruction of our trade and the kidnapping of our men by England, as trivial things; I ask you; what you will admit to be an "essential injury" on her part?

Don't you think that Britain should pay us for the property of which she has robbed us, to the amount of about one hundred and fifty millions of dollars in a few years?

What right has England to interrupt our commerce with any nation on earth? Ought not neutral trade to be free?

How far ought we to follow English notions and fashions?

What have genuine Americans to do with English monarchy or French despotism, but to avoid both forever?

Were we not inoculated with the former of these disorders before '76'; and being cured of it then, why should be we infected with it again?

The federalists recommend British principles to cure us of French influence—but, why should we have either? or if we have, how can a plaster applied to the shin, cure us of the tooth ache?

Did you ever see a single patient under the imaginary disorder of French influence; and if you did, why not give him a strait waistcoat or mad shirt?

Are not American air, diet, principles and patriotism, the only true antidote to all foreign diseases of the body politic?

A little more, and I have done:

Since England prohibits our manufactures why ought we not to shut out hers?

If we consent to an ignominious trade with those who rob us, and murder our citizens how can we expect to obtain redress, or respect?

I allow the Washington society of Maryland; alias, the St. George's society, three days and three nights to answer the foregoing,

A '76-ER

What sub-type of article is it?

Foreign Affairs Partisan Politics War Or Peace

What keywords are associated?

Federalist Hypocrisy British Orders In Council Neutral Trade Rights Impressment American Neutrality French Decrees War Of 1812 Tensions

What entities or persons were involved?

Federalists Bonaparte England Britain Washington Society St. George's Society

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Critique Of Federalist Bias Toward Britain Over French Actions In Neutral Trade Disputes

Stance / Tone

Strongly Anti Federalist And Pro Neutral American Rights

Key Figures

Federalists Bonaparte England Britain Washington Society St. George's Society

Key Arguments

Federalists Hypocritically Criticize French Rescinding Of Decrees But Defend British Orders In Council Anger At French Release Of American Vessels Contrasts With Silence On British Condemnations British Impressment And Trade Destruction Are Essential Injuries Requiring Compensation Neutral Trade Should Be Free Without British Interference Americans Should Avoid Both English Monarchy And French Despotism British Principles Cannot Cure Imaginary French Influence American Patriotism Is The Antidote To Foreign Influences Reciprocate British Prohibitions On Manufactures By Excluding Theirs Continuing Trade With Britain Undermines Redress For Injuries

Are you sure?