Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
August 29, 1803
Jenks' Portland Gazette. And Maine Advertiser
Portland, Cumberland County, Maine
What is this article about?
Criticism of the Louisiana Purchase as an unpopular, expensive acquisition of unnecessary land that devalues existing territories, incurs future costs for governance and defense, and sacrifices rights to Mississippi navigation previously secured by treaty.
OCR Quality
95%
Excellent
Full Text
Louisiana.—The purchase of this vast wilderness is not so generally well received as the President's tools and flatterers endeavored to make it. The people seem desirous to pause, inquire and reflect on the subject, before they approve or condemn—without having it forced upon them as the master stroke of human wisdom. From the late remarks we have thus far seen, we deem it a bad speculation. But as it will soon meet the decision of Congress, we will then give our readers an opportunity to avail themselves of the arguments on both sides the question.
Fifteen Millions of Dollars for Louisiana!—This is a bargain that does not meet with unqualified approbation in the public papers. When the people seriously contemplate the payment of this great sum, they begin to think they do not stand much in need of that vast country, with all its Indians. They find, by looking at the map of the United States in its present limits, that they have millions and millions of acres of unsettled land, more than they will populate for centuries; and that the purchase of more, can only have the effect to sink the value of what they now possess. What, we are in need of (the free navigation of the Mississippi, and a convenient place of deposit, for the benefit of our western brethren) we did own, by solemn treaty with Spain. That nation, with whom we have now a long unsettled account for the depredations of their gun boats on our commerce in the straits, and the imprisonment and slaughter of our countrymen, dared (for, alas! our Washington was no more) to deprive us of the latter; and rather than claim our right, we suffer ourselves to pay tribute to the amount of Fifteen Millions of Dollars! Perhaps, indeed, our Senate may still preserve us from this humiliation—they may still refuse the tribute, and demand our right—and should the government do this, with proper spirit, neither France nor Spain could withhold it from us.—Solem Gas.
The country of Louisiana costs us fifteen millions of dollars, in the first instance, to France.—But before we have a clear title to it, we must pay the Indians for it also, besides, probably, maintaining wars with them into the bargain. To preserve what we buy, we must establish a government in the country; and we must build forts, and raise troops to support that government. The fifteen millions of dollars, we apprehend, is the cheapest part of the bargain; as it is well known the defence and government of our Western Territory have been the heaviest bill of expense to us of any one article since the establishment of the Federal Constitution; and there can scarcely be a hope that the people of that country, when it shall contain a people capable of government, will not set up for independence, and form a separate nation. But before that time many a land jobber may have made his fortune by Louisiana speculations.—Ibid.
Fifteen Millions of Dollars for Louisiana!—This is a bargain that does not meet with unqualified approbation in the public papers. When the people seriously contemplate the payment of this great sum, they begin to think they do not stand much in need of that vast country, with all its Indians. They find, by looking at the map of the United States in its present limits, that they have millions and millions of acres of unsettled land, more than they will populate for centuries; and that the purchase of more, can only have the effect to sink the value of what they now possess. What, we are in need of (the free navigation of the Mississippi, and a convenient place of deposit, for the benefit of our western brethren) we did own, by solemn treaty with Spain. That nation, with whom we have now a long unsettled account for the depredations of their gun boats on our commerce in the straits, and the imprisonment and slaughter of our countrymen, dared (for, alas! our Washington was no more) to deprive us of the latter; and rather than claim our right, we suffer ourselves to pay tribute to the amount of Fifteen Millions of Dollars! Perhaps, indeed, our Senate may still preserve us from this humiliation—they may still refuse the tribute, and demand our right—and should the government do this, with proper spirit, neither France nor Spain could withhold it from us.—Solem Gas.
The country of Louisiana costs us fifteen millions of dollars, in the first instance, to France.—But before we have a clear title to it, we must pay the Indians for it also, besides, probably, maintaining wars with them into the bargain. To preserve what we buy, we must establish a government in the country; and we must build forts, and raise troops to support that government. The fifteen millions of dollars, we apprehend, is the cheapest part of the bargain; as it is well known the defence and government of our Western Territory have been the heaviest bill of expense to us of any one article since the establishment of the Federal Constitution; and there can scarcely be a hope that the people of that country, when it shall contain a people capable of government, will not set up for independence, and form a separate nation. But before that time many a land jobber may have made his fortune by Louisiana speculations.—Ibid.
What sub-type of article is it?
Foreign Affairs
Economic Policy
Imperialism
What keywords are associated?
Louisiana Purchase
Territorial Expansion
Economic Cost
Mississippi Navigation
Indian Affairs
Western Territory
Land Speculation
What entities or persons were involved?
France
Spain
Congress
Senate
Indians
President
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Criticism Of The Louisiana Purchase
Stance / Tone
Strongly Critical Of The Purchase As A Bad Speculation
Key Figures
France
Spain
Congress
Senate
Indians
President
Key Arguments
Purchase Of Louisiana Not Generally Well Received
Fifteen Million Dollars Is Excessive For Unnecessary Vast Wilderness
Existing U.S. Lands Sufficient For Centuries
Purchase Sinks Value Of Current Unsettled Lands
Loss Of Free Mississippi Navigation Rights Secured By Treaty With Spain
Additional Costs For Indian Payments, Wars, Government, Forts, And Troops
Western Territories Already Expensive To Defend
Future Risk Of Louisiana's Independence
Opportunity For Land Speculators To Profit