Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Barre Daily Times
Letter to Editor March 15, 1909

The Barre Daily Times

Barre, Washington County, Vermont

What is this article about?

In a letter to the Barre Times, F.B. Martin, a dairy dealer, argues against mandatory tuberculosis testing for cattle in Vermont, citing the test's unreliability, uncompensated losses from slaughtering healthy animals, and inevitable rise in milk prices. Dated March 15, 1909.

Clipping

OCR Quality

100% Excellent

Full Text

One Barre Dealer Has Something to Say.

Calls It Injustice.

Editor, Times: I see by the Barre Times of March 13 that a farmer, in order to be able to dispose of his milk product, must have all his herd tested for tuberculosis by a veterinary and pronounced O. K. That sounds good, but to the farmer that means something more. First, it is an acknowledged fact by all competent veterinaries that the tuberculin test is not reliable. It is also an understood fact that thousands of cows are slaughtered under this test and examination has found them to be undiseased. Now, then, will the state of Vermont or city of Barre pay the farmer full value for these cattle so slaughtered? No! although they are his pride, they are slaughtered and found to be unaffected; a farmer has no recourse but to take what is handed by the state. To a farmer who knows that good cows are scarce like good men, it looks like a big injustice, as it surely is.

I for one welcome an inspection for my stable, milk and cattle; but if there is no trouble found in either of these places, I do not believe the right exists to test our cattle by injecting something into their systems which is an injury from which they never fully recover. Our herd of thirty-eight cattle are all in a healthy condition. There never was a case of tuberculosis on this farm, to my knowledge; neither is there one today. They have been from four to eight cows old in the local market for beef every year, and these were always satisfactory and never a disease developed.

Now, be this as it may, if this is carried into effect there must someone reimburse the farmer for the loss he suffers, and it is inevitable that it must come out of the consumer. In this, like all others, the more legislation, the greater the cost of living. If the city of Barre demands certified milk, then let the dealers demand what that product is worth.

I will not sign my name 'Constant Reader,' but

F. B. Martin.

March 15, 1909.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Informative Social Critique

What themes does it cover?

Agriculture Health Medicine Economic Policy

What keywords are associated?

Tuberculosis Testing Cattle Slaughter Farmer Injustice Milk Regulation Vermont Dairy Tuberculin Test Unreliability

What entities or persons were involved?

F. B. Martin Editor, Times

Letter to Editor Details

Author

F. B. Martin

Recipient

Editor, Times

Main Argument

mandatory tuberculosis testing for cattle is unjust because the tuberculin test is unreliable, leading to the slaughter of healthy cows without compensation to farmers, and it will increase the cost of milk for consumers due to added legislation.

Notable Details

References Barre Times Of March 13 Acknowledges Unreliability Of Tuberculin Test And Thousands Of Healthy Cows Slaughtered Farmer's Herd Of 38 Cattle Healthy With No Tuberculosis History Cows Sold For Beef Annually Without Disease Issues

Are you sure?