Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
November 23, 1836
Morning Star
Limerick, York County, Maine
What is this article about?
Humorous excerpt from an English paper detailing the myriad troubles faced by newspaper editors, including criticism for opinions, poetry submissions, and subscriber demands for changes in style and format. The piece satirizes the impossibility of pleasing everyone.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
Editorial Troubles.—The following disclosures of an editor's troubles are from an English paper. If the author has disclosed all his troubles, or even the hundredth part of them, he must have been a singularly fortunate man, and must have lived in other times. An editor—but it won't do, somebody will suspect us of intentions upon them.
"An editor cannot step without treading on somebody's toes. If he expresses his opinion fearlessly and frankly, he is arrogant and presumptuous; if he merely states facts without comment, he dares not avow his sentiments. If he conscientiously refuses to advocate the claims of an individual to office, he is accused of personal hostility. A Jackanapes who measures off words into verse as a clerk does tape by the yard, hands him a parcel of stuff that jingles like a handful of rusty nails and a gimblet, and if the editor is not fool enough to print the nonsense—'Stop my paper, I won't patronize a man that is no better judge of poetry!' One murmurs because his paper is too literary; another, because it is not literary enough; one would have the type so small that a microscope would be indispensable in every family; another threatens to discontinue his paper unless the letters are half an inch long. In fact, every subscriber has a plan of his own for conducting a journal, and the labor of Sisyphus was recreation, when compared with that of an editor who undertakes to please all."
"An editor cannot step without treading on somebody's toes. If he expresses his opinion fearlessly and frankly, he is arrogant and presumptuous; if he merely states facts without comment, he dares not avow his sentiments. If he conscientiously refuses to advocate the claims of an individual to office, he is accused of personal hostility. A Jackanapes who measures off words into verse as a clerk does tape by the yard, hands him a parcel of stuff that jingles like a handful of rusty nails and a gimblet, and if the editor is not fool enough to print the nonsense—'Stop my paper, I won't patronize a man that is no better judge of poetry!' One murmurs because his paper is too literary; another, because it is not literary enough; one would have the type so small that a microscope would be indispensable in every family; another threatens to discontinue his paper unless the letters are half an inch long. In fact, every subscriber has a plan of his own for conducting a journal, and the labor of Sisyphus was recreation, when compared with that of an editor who undertakes to please all."
What sub-type of article is it?
Press Freedom
Satire
What keywords are associated?
Editor Troubles
Subscriber Complaints
Newspaper Challenges
Press Difficulties
Satirical Commentary
What entities or persons were involved?
Editors
Subscribers
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Challenges Of Newspaper Editing
Stance / Tone
Humorous Satire Of Editorial Difficulties
Key Figures
Editors
Subscribers
Key Arguments
Editors Face Criticism For Expressing Opinions Or Withholding Them
Refusing To Promote Individuals Leads To Accusations Of Hostility
Poor Poetry Submissions Result In Subscription Cancellations
Subscribers Complain About Literary Level, Type Size, And Format
Pleasing All Subscribers Is An Impossible Task Like Sisyphus's Labor