Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Daily Dispatch
Editorial October 29, 1870

The Daily Dispatch

Richmond, Virginia

What is this article about?

The editorial criticizes American philanthropists, led by Charles Sumner, for opposing war in Europe while supporting harsh punishment and potential violence against the post-Civil War South, highlighting their hypocrisy in advocating peace abroad but tyranny at home.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Philanthropists and War.—The American philanthropists are all opposed to war in other countries, but at home it is a different matter. Sumner is lecturing upon "The Duel between France and Germany, with its Lesson to Civilization." He asserts that the dismemberment of France is not the only guarantee of peace that is required : the disarmament of all Europe is necessary to general peace, and this is demanded by civilization. Thus we see Sumner's, and the school of humanitarians of which he is a sort of leader, inveighing against war elsewhere, while in this country war could not be too bloody and ruthless for them. What is still worse, there is no measure of punishment of the southern people, no disfranchisement, no oppression too odious for the revengeful and rancorous stomachs of these philanthropists. All the tyrannies and persecutions that engender resistance and war are to them proper and grateful as long as they are visited upon the unfortunate people who differ from them and oppose their fanatical dogmas. But they cannot bear to see the rod wielded by others than themselves, and cannot tolerate war and bloodshed save to support their doctrines, and when waged for them too much blood cannot be shed.

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics War Or Peace Moral Or Religious

What keywords are associated?

Philanthropists War Hypocrisy Sumner Lectures Southern Punishment Reconstruction Tyranny European Disarmament

What entities or persons were involved?

Sumner American Philanthropists Southern People France Germany

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Hypocrisy Of Philanthropists On War Abroad Versus Southern Oppression At Home

Stance / Tone

Critical And Sarcastic

Key Figures

Sumner American Philanthropists Southern People France Germany

Key Arguments

Philanthropists Oppose War In Other Countries But Support It At Home Sumner Lectures On The Need For European Disarmament For Peace No Punishment Of Southerners Is Too Severe For These Humanitarians They Approve Tyrannies Against Those Opposing Their Dogmas They Tolerate War Only When It Supports Their Doctrines

Are you sure?