Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Story
March 12, 1912
The Bennington Evening Banner
Bennington, Bennington County, Vermont
What is this article about?
Commentary on the practice of U.S. congressmen plagiarizing each other's bills without credit or permission, contrasting it with protections in other fields like journalism and literature. Unused bills are archived for future reuse by ambitious legislators.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
Congressional Plagiarism.
The custom of "lifting" a brother congressman's bills without sanction or permission has resulted in a warm discussion concerning the ethics of legislation. In newspaper work, novel writing or any other strenuous employment the appropriation or use of another man's words or ideas entitles him to credit and legal protection. Not so, however, in the legislative hopper. If one man fails to have a resolution or bill passed another takes it up, transferring such paragraphs and clauses or ideas as he wishes, without credit, and labeling the result with his name in such a way as to secure full and undisputed possession.
The only question considered is, "will it pass?" for if it does not pass it represents only so much white paper snugly tucked away in pigeonholes until the advent of the next legislator whose inclination runs to fathering bills. The pigeonholes and crypt at the capitol are filled with documents suggestive of the faded hopes of many an enthusiastic congressman whose bill failed to "get by" and is ready for the appropriation of another ambitious legislator.-National Magazine.
The custom of "lifting" a brother congressman's bills without sanction or permission has resulted in a warm discussion concerning the ethics of legislation. In newspaper work, novel writing or any other strenuous employment the appropriation or use of another man's words or ideas entitles him to credit and legal protection. Not so, however, in the legislative hopper. If one man fails to have a resolution or bill passed another takes it up, transferring such paragraphs and clauses or ideas as he wishes, without credit, and labeling the result with his name in such a way as to secure full and undisputed possession.
The only question considered is, "will it pass?" for if it does not pass it represents only so much white paper snugly tucked away in pigeonholes until the advent of the next legislator whose inclination runs to fathering bills. The pigeonholes and crypt at the capitol are filled with documents suggestive of the faded hopes of many an enthusiastic congressman whose bill failed to "get by" and is ready for the appropriation of another ambitious legislator.-National Magazine.
What sub-type of article is it?
Curiosity
Deception Fraud
What themes does it cover?
Deception
Moral Virtue
What keywords are associated?
Congressional Plagiarism
Bill Reuse
Legislative Ethics
Capitol Archives
Where did it happen?
Capitol
Story Details
Location
Capitol
Story Details
Custom of congressmen reusing failed bills without credit sparks ethics debate; contrasts with protections in other professions; unused bills archived for future appropriation.