Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Carbon Advocate
Editorial January 16, 1875

The Carbon Advocate

Lehighton, Carbon County, Pennsylvania

What is this article about?

Editorial quoting 'The Christian at Work' criticizes President Grant's military interference in Louisiana's legislature as a violation of state rights and federalism, warning of broader threats to all states.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

The Christian at Work in discussing affairs in Louisiana, says: "Nor should this matter be regarded at all from merely a sectional standpoint—it becomes a national matter, and the question arises, Have the States any right which the Federal Government is bound to respect? An unwarrantable and dangerous departure from the organic law upon which our Republican Government is founded—this military interference by the President's direction is indefensible and utterly without the shadow of right. It is not only an insult to the State, it is a direct challenge as well to the Government and people of every State in the Union; for as was forcibly said a century ago, the right to tax a penny was a right to tax a pound, so if the President has a right to disperse the Legislature of one State, why may he not crush out the Governments of every State in the Union? We are not unmindful of General Grant's services to his country, but neither his services nor his abilities are matters of consideration when he tramples upon popular right as in this instance; on the contrary, distinguished services only make failure and wrongdoing the more conspicuous."

What sub-type of article is it?

Constitutional

What keywords are associated?

Federal Interference State Rights Military Dispersion Grant Louisiana Constitutional Violation

What entities or persons were involved?

President Grant General Grant Federal Government Louisiana States

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Opposition To Federal Military Interference In Louisiana State Legislature

Stance / Tone

Strongly Critical Of Presidential Overreach

Key Figures

President Grant General Grant Federal Government Louisiana States

Key Arguments

Matter Is National, Not Sectional Federal Government Must Respect State Rights Military Interference Is Unwarrantable Departure From Organic Law Indefensible And Without Right Insult To The State And Challenge To All States Analogy: Right To Disperse One Legislature Implies Right To Crush All Grant's Services Do Not Excuse Trampling Popular Rights Distinguished Services Make Wrongdoing More Conspicuous

Are you sure?