Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Sun
Story November 29, 1861

The Sun

New York, New York County, New York

What is this article about?

Laconic telegraph exchange between General Ignatieff and the Russian Emperor about student unrest at Moscow University. Ignatieff interprets 'treat like a father' as arresting 283 students, many wounded, prompting the Emperor's remonstrance. Explanation ties to Russian language lacking articles.

Clipping

OCR Quality

75% Good

Full Text

Laconic Correspondence
The recent troubles between the students of
the University of Moscow and the officers of the
Russian Government, gave rise to this Laconic
but pointed correspondence, transmitted by
telegraph:-
GENERAL IGNATIEFF TO THE EMPEROR.
"Great disturbances at the University. The
students will listen to no one: neither to the
rector, nor to the curator, nor even to me.
What is to be done?"
THE EMPEROR TO IGNATIEFF
"Make every effort to calm the students.
Treat them like a father."
IGNATIEFF'S REPLY.
"I have obeyed your Majesty's command.
The students are in the fortress."
THE EMPEROR'S REMONDER.
"What do you mean? You have committed
some dreadful blunder."
It's clear that Ignatieff's notion of "fatherly
treatment" was not in accordance with the Em-
peror's ideas, but the unlucky General subse-
quently made an explanation, seeking to jus-
tify it after this fashion:
"I endeavored, Sire, to execute your orders.
I arrested two hundred and eighty-three stu-
dents last Thursday, and many of them are bad-
ly wounded. Your lamented father could scarce-
ly have done more."
The italicised words are certainly to the point.
We are indebted to the London Times for a
commentary, which may throw some light
upon the question at issue:
The explanation of poor General Ignatieff's
sad mistake is to be found in the fact that
there are no articles in the Russian language,
and in such phrases as 'like my father,' or
'as his father' (would have done) the possessive
is usually omitted—P.S.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event Curiosity

What themes does it cover?

Deception Misfortune Justice

What keywords are associated?

Student Unrest Moscow University Ignatieff Russian Emperor Arrests Telegraph Correspondence

What entities or persons were involved?

Ignatieff Emperor

Where did it happen?

University Of Moscow

Story Details

Key Persons

Ignatieff Emperor

Location

University Of Moscow

Story Details

General Ignatieff reports student disturbances at Moscow University to the Emperor, who advises treating them like a father. Ignatieff arrests 283 students, many wounded, interpreting it paternally. The Emperor remonstrates, and Ignatieff justifies by comparing to the late Emperor, explained by Russian grammar omitting possessives.

Are you sure?