Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
May 20, 1894
The Indianapolis Journal
Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana
What is this article about?
Editorial criticizes Indianapolis Western League baseball team's poor performance due to mismanagement, urges hiring top players like Perry Werden, ignoring salary limits, appointing a captain, and acquiring loans like pitcher Cross from Cincinnati to improve and boost attendance.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
SOME PROMPT ACTION NEEDED.
The Indianapolis Management Has Allowed Its Team to Be Outclassed.
A minor league team never started out with better prospects than did the Indianapolis baseball club this season, but those prospects are being killed about as rapidly as possible. It is too bad that such is the case and it would seem as if there ought to be some way to build up the team but nobody connected with the management appears able to make the right move. As has frequently been remarked, this city, with a team able to stand up among the first four in the race, would prove one of the best, if not the best, in the Western League. It is not an exacting class of patrons that attend the ball games here. On the contrary, they are patient and ever ready to forgive and forget, and are loyal to the core, but they cannot stand everything. They have gone on this season, hoping against hope, only to see the team that misrepresents a good city defeated time after time, and by discreditable scores. It is an actual disgrace to a city to have a ball team bearing its name give such miserable exhibitions as has Indianapolis in many of the championship games this season. The club has already become the laughing stock of the league, and is lamentably outclassed by the other clubs with the single exception of Detroit. There is little hope that it will win a single game on the present trip, and such a record will not be calculated to keep in line even the "regulars" who never desert their baseball colors.
The trouble is that in the start the mistake was made of holding the Western League too cheaply. If Indianapolis had made a poor showing in the exhibition games it would have been better for the club and the city. The teams that were not stronger than Indianapolis at the beginning soon spent enough money to make themselves formidable. This city and Detroit have floundered along with clubs that have put up ragged, wretched ball and fairly earned the discreditable positions in the race they now occupy. If it is necessary to pay two or three big salaries in order to get good players there should be no hesitancy in doing so. It is certainly more profitable to expend a little more money with every assurance of solid returns than to drift along and see the club wrecked on the shore of bad attendance, as it surely will be if new players are not taken in at once, not makeshifts, but men who can push the team into a winning gait.
The Journal has repeatedly urged that a captain be secured, something the club has never yet had. Its utter lack of a playing head has cost it runs, and doubtless games. Something should be done without further delay to remedy this and the other shortcomings. Minneapolis secured Perry Werden by paying him $250 a month, after he had refused Milwaukee's offer of $225. Indianapolis can afford to pay as much as any other club for its players, and there is no attempt on the part of six of them, so it is said, to keep within the salary limit. Indianapolis and Detroit are observing this dead-letter provision of the Western League constitution, and the result is apparent by a glance at the standing of the clubs. That is a silent but eloquent homily on the fallacy of the salary limit in this organization. Milwaukee will not remain long at the foot. It must be remembered that Cushman's players have done little playing since the team was strengthened, the weather having interfered with their games right along. They will be heard from in due time. Grand Rapids pays her four crack hitters, Wright, Carroll, Caruthers and George close to $1,000 a month. The remaining nine or ten players, among whom are Pinckney and Wheelock, ex-Leaguers, draw an aggregate of considerably more than $600 a month, as everybody knows. Two or three good, hard hitters and old Leaguers like Werden, Crooks, Carroll or Caruthers, would help Indianapolis out wonderfully. The management should let go some money, if necessary, and get some men who can play ball.
Manager Sharsig telegraphed last night that he had given Snyder and McTammany their five days' notice. These men have been released about every twenty-eight minutes during the past two weeks, and the announcement is therefore nothing of a surprise. He does not say that he has replaced them with anything better, but it is to be hoped so. He is after several players, but thus far there is no indication that any of them have been secured. President Brush, of the Cincinnati team, could better afford to let Cross pitch for Indianapolis than to keep him idle in that city. By loaning him to the Hoosier club Cincinnati would benefit all around. Cross would be in fast company enough to keep him in good pitching condition, would be off the Cincinnati pay roll and could be telegraphed for as easily here as anywhere. As it is he gets no actual practice and is on the bench, useless to himself and to the club. The Cincinnati president went to St. Louis last night and said he would see about sending "Connie" Murphy to the Hoosiers' relief, but was noncommittal about Cross. Sharsig's men play their last game at Minneapolis to-day, and then go to Sioux City for three games.
The Indianapolis Management Has Allowed Its Team to Be Outclassed.
A minor league team never started out with better prospects than did the Indianapolis baseball club this season, but those prospects are being killed about as rapidly as possible. It is too bad that such is the case and it would seem as if there ought to be some way to build up the team but nobody connected with the management appears able to make the right move. As has frequently been remarked, this city, with a team able to stand up among the first four in the race, would prove one of the best, if not the best, in the Western League. It is not an exacting class of patrons that attend the ball games here. On the contrary, they are patient and ever ready to forgive and forget, and are loyal to the core, but they cannot stand everything. They have gone on this season, hoping against hope, only to see the team that misrepresents a good city defeated time after time, and by discreditable scores. It is an actual disgrace to a city to have a ball team bearing its name give such miserable exhibitions as has Indianapolis in many of the championship games this season. The club has already become the laughing stock of the league, and is lamentably outclassed by the other clubs with the single exception of Detroit. There is little hope that it will win a single game on the present trip, and such a record will not be calculated to keep in line even the "regulars" who never desert their baseball colors.
The trouble is that in the start the mistake was made of holding the Western League too cheaply. If Indianapolis had made a poor showing in the exhibition games it would have been better for the club and the city. The teams that were not stronger than Indianapolis at the beginning soon spent enough money to make themselves formidable. This city and Detroit have floundered along with clubs that have put up ragged, wretched ball and fairly earned the discreditable positions in the race they now occupy. If it is necessary to pay two or three big salaries in order to get good players there should be no hesitancy in doing so. It is certainly more profitable to expend a little more money with every assurance of solid returns than to drift along and see the club wrecked on the shore of bad attendance, as it surely will be if new players are not taken in at once, not makeshifts, but men who can push the team into a winning gait.
The Journal has repeatedly urged that a captain be secured, something the club has never yet had. Its utter lack of a playing head has cost it runs, and doubtless games. Something should be done without further delay to remedy this and the other shortcomings. Minneapolis secured Perry Werden by paying him $250 a month, after he had refused Milwaukee's offer of $225. Indianapolis can afford to pay as much as any other club for its players, and there is no attempt on the part of six of them, so it is said, to keep within the salary limit. Indianapolis and Detroit are observing this dead-letter provision of the Western League constitution, and the result is apparent by a glance at the standing of the clubs. That is a silent but eloquent homily on the fallacy of the salary limit in this organization. Milwaukee will not remain long at the foot. It must be remembered that Cushman's players have done little playing since the team was strengthened, the weather having interfered with their games right along. They will be heard from in due time. Grand Rapids pays her four crack hitters, Wright, Carroll, Caruthers and George close to $1,000 a month. The remaining nine or ten players, among whom are Pinckney and Wheelock, ex-Leaguers, draw an aggregate of considerably more than $600 a month, as everybody knows. Two or three good, hard hitters and old Leaguers like Werden, Crooks, Carroll or Caruthers, would help Indianapolis out wonderfully. The management should let go some money, if necessary, and get some men who can play ball.
Manager Sharsig telegraphed last night that he had given Snyder and McTammany their five days' notice. These men have been released about every twenty-eight minutes during the past two weeks, and the announcement is therefore nothing of a surprise. He does not say that he has replaced them with anything better, but it is to be hoped so. He is after several players, but thus far there is no indication that any of them have been secured. President Brush, of the Cincinnati team, could better afford to let Cross pitch for Indianapolis than to keep him idle in that city. By loaning him to the Hoosier club Cincinnati would benefit all around. Cross would be in fast company enough to keep him in good pitching condition, would be off the Cincinnati pay roll and could be telegraphed for as easily here as anywhere. As it is he gets no actual practice and is on the bench, useless to himself and to the club. The Cincinnati president went to St. Louis last night and said he would see about sending "Connie" Murphy to the Hoosiers' relief, but was noncommittal about Cross. Sharsig's men play their last game at Minneapolis to-day, and then go to Sioux City for three games.
What sub-type of article is it?
Sports Management
Baseball Criticism
What keywords are associated?
Indianapolis Baseball
Western League
Team Management
Player Salaries
Salary Limit
Player Releases
Minneapolis
Detroit
Milwaukee
Grand Rapids
What entities or persons were involved?
Indianapolis Baseball Club
Western League
Manager Sharsig
President Brush
Perry Werden
Snyder
Mctammany
Cross
Connie Murphy
Minneapolis
Detroit
Milwaukee
Grand Rapids
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Criticism Of Indianapolis Baseball Team Management
Stance / Tone
Urgent Call For Prompt Action And Investment In Better Players
Key Figures
Indianapolis Baseball Club
Western League
Manager Sharsig
President Brush
Perry Werden
Snyder
Mctammany
Cross
Connie Murphy
Minneapolis
Detroit
Milwaukee
Grand Rapids
Key Arguments
Team Started With Good Prospects But Is Being Mismanaged And Outclassed
Fans Are Loyal But Frustrated By Repeated Defeats
Mistake Of Underestimating The League Led To Weak Roster
Need To Spend On High Salary Players Like Werden To Compete
Lack Of A Captain Has Cost Games
Salary Limit Hinders Indianapolis While Others Ignore It
Release Of Underperforming Players Like Snyder And Mctammany
Suggestions To Loan Players Like Cross From Cincinnati