Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Tribune And Telegraph
Story June 19, 1856

Tribune And Telegraph

Kenosha, Kenosha County, Wisconsin

What is this article about?

Senate debate in Washington on June 13 where Butler claims to refute Sumner's speech, referencing Sumner's assault-related confinement. Wilson defends Sumner, accuses Butler of prior insults, and they exchange retorts about Revolutionary War battles in Massachusetts and South Carolina.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Congressional.

Washington, June 13

Senate.—Butler concluded his remarks by claiming he had convicted Sumner of error, misrepresentation and calumny.

Wilson replied sustaining Sumner's position by stating that from the 29th May, Sumner had been confined to his room the greater part of the time, in consequence of the assault and would be unable to attend to business for some time to come.

Butler had taken a full revenge for the speech delivered by Sumner. This is the way it should have been met, and not by blows.

Mr. Wilson endorsed Sumner's remarks relative to South Carolina, and referred to former speeches of Butler to show that ever since Butler has been in the Senate, his replies to Sumner have been in offensive epithets, calculated to injure the feelings of any man, and insisted that Butler was the first aggressor.

Wilson said he would speak his feelings freely—no one held over him 'plantation whips, he would speak more freely because his colleague was stricken down in debate.

Butler said Wilson had no right to go back to old reports to show cause for Sumner's speech, because Sumner in affidavit said his speech was in reply to Butler's speeches of this session He asked Wilson how many battles there were in Massachusetts during the Revolution.

Wilson replied, "Not many, because the enemy considered it safer to go to South Carolina. They met them at Concord, Bunker Hill, Lexington and Dorchester Heights, and would have met them elsewhere, but the enemy took good care to keep out of sight."

Evans obtained the floor.

Adjourned till Monday.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Justice Revenge Bravery Heroism

What keywords are associated?

Senate Debate Sumner Assault Butler Wilson Exchange Revolutionary War Retort Congressional Session

What entities or persons were involved?

Butler Sumner Wilson Evans

Where did it happen?

Washington

Story Details

Key Persons

Butler Sumner Wilson Evans

Location

Washington

Event Date

June 13

Story Details

Butler concludes debate claiming to convict Sumner of errors amid references to Sumner's assault confinement. Wilson defends Sumner, accuses Butler of prior aggression with offensive epithets, asserts free speech without 'plantation whips,' and retorts on Revolutionary battles in Massachusetts versus South Carolina. Evans gains floor; adjournment to Monday.

Are you sure?