Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Enquirer
Editorial July 8, 1808

The Enquirer

Richmond, Henrico County, Virginia

What is this article about?

An editorial denounces Citizen Cheetham for defamatory claims that Virginia leaders, including Madison, plot to divide New York into two states to diminish its influence and secure Virginia's dominance. The author refutes this, arguing it contradicts Virginia's interests in the Senate and lacks evidence, while defending Governor Clinton.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Citizen Cheetham seems rapidly improving in the honorable career of defamation and intrigue, which he has lately trod. Mark the low artifice & unblushing effrontery of the following tale! This man has boldly and unblushingly asserted, that "the state of New-York is an eye-sore at the South; that certain men of Virginia tremble for their ascendancy: that already is New-York divided into two states upon paper: that in Mr. Madison's desk it is now divided; and that if the leading men in Virginia can succeed in this pernicious scheme, N. York will be reduced in her consequence, and Virginia dominion be established forever." Has this miserable calumniator forgotten, that it is really the interest of Virginia to prevent, instead of promoting the division of states; because in proportion as you increase the number of states, you decrease the weight of her influence in the Senate of the United States? Does he not perceive, that his miserable tale proves too much; for instead of confining the principle of division to New-York alone; Mr. Madison should on the same principle equally extend his views to the other great states of the Union, particularly to, Massachusetts and Pennsylvania? But where is Cheetham's proof of these other projects? or rather where is his proof of the specific charge, which he has dared to urge? Not one tittle has he produced—It is impossible, that the gallant and venerable Clinton can countenance the tales of such a man!

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics Constitutional

What keywords are associated?

Political Defamation State Division Virginia Influence Cheetham Calumny Clinton Defense

What entities or persons were involved?

Citizen Cheetham Mr. Madison Clinton Virginia New York

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Refutation Of Plot To Divide New York State

Stance / Tone

Strongly Critical Of Cheetham, Defensive Of New York And Clinton

Key Figures

Citizen Cheetham Mr. Madison Clinton Virginia New York

Key Arguments

Cheetham's Claims Of Virginia Plotting To Divide New York Lack Proof Dividing States Would Reduce Virginia's Senate Influence, Against Their Interest Cheetham's Tale Implies Similar Divisions For Other States Like Massachusetts And Pennsylvania Without Evidence Clinton Would Not Support Such Tales

Are you sure?