Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Virginia Gazette
Letter to Editor October 29, 1736

The Virginia Gazette

Richmond, Williamsburg, Richmond County, Virginia

What is this article about?

A letter defends music, particularly the Italian Opera, against critics who apply dramatic rules to it, arguing that it is a valuable innocent amusement essential for mental health and capable of expressing noble passions with attention and clarity of mind.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

The Subject of Musick has been so often pointed out by every little Genius, that any Man who will condescend to write or speak against it, without saying a Thousand pretty Things, must take a deal of Pains to miss them.

To consider the Italian Opera, as a meer Dramatical Entertainment, is requiring of it what it does not profess. But so many fine Things have been so often repeated upon the Opposition between Sound and Sense, that at last they consider it as real and solid Truth: As to the Precepts concerning Dictions, Sentiments, and Unities, I would have my Friend Zachary keep them for the Stage, whose Business it is to observe them: A good Ear has infinitely more Right to form a Judgment on the Matter in Hand, at an Entertainment of Musick, than a Man who has spent a Life in Rapin, Aristotle, or Bossu without it. A queamish Critic with no Ear for Musick, when present at an Elegant Entertainment, Vocal and Instrumental, is out of his Element, and makes the drollest of Figures; he is dying at the Impropriety of an Incident, while the rest of the Audience are charm'd with an Air: And, while everyone is listening with Attention to a beautiful Symphony, he is inconsolable for the Want of a Sentiment.

I have known it urg'd against Musick, as a Proof of its Irrationality, that it is only an Amusement. I should be very sorry to be Rational; if to maintain that Character, I were to renounce the Enjoyment of innocent Amusements. Recreations and Diversions, are as essential to the Preservation of Health and Vigour in the Mind, as Exercise is to the Body; the one wou'd be no more fit for Thinking, than the other for Motion, without the due Refreshments of the Spirits.

Allow Musick therefore to be nothing but a meer Amusement, that very Qualification (especially when at the same Time innocent,) ought to render it acceptable to a reasonable Man; the nobler Passions and Affections of the Mind, are capable of being express'd by it with equal Force and Delicacy, as by either of its Sister Arts, Painting, or Poetry. Nor is its being only conversant in Sound, any Objection to its Furnishing a proper Employment to the Understanding. But it has this further to say for itself, that no One can enjoy this Pleasure completely without the Habit of Attention, and Clearness of Head, which is universally useful in every Thing a Man has Occasion to apply to.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Philosophical Reflective

What keywords are associated?

Italian Opera Music Defense Sound Vs Sense Innocent Amusement Mental Refreshment Cultural Criticism Dramatic Rules

Letter to Editor Details

Main Argument

music, including the italian opera, should not be judged by dramatic precepts but valued as an innocent amusement that refreshes the mind, expresses noble passions like painting and poetry, and requires attention beneficial to understanding.

Notable Details

Opposition Between Sound And Sense Precepts Concerning Dictions, Sentiments, And Unities References To Rapin, Aristotle, Bossu Music As Essential To Mental Health Like Exercise To Body Comparison To Sister Arts: Painting, Poetry

Are you sure?