Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Deseret Evening News
Story September 20, 1910

Deseret Evening News

Salt Lake City, Salt Lake County, Utah

What is this article about?

Excerpts from Chicago Record-Herald and New York Evening Post criticizing the partisan tactics and procedural flaws in the Ballinger investigating committee, highlighting the failure to properly discuss evidence and the snap judgments by both sides.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

BUNGLING IN BALLINGER CASE.
Chicago Record-Herald.
Recognition of the fact that Secretary Ballinger has been too heavy a load for the administration to carry, and that his voluntary retirement would have been an act of loyalty and gratitude, should not preclude frank and vigorous criticism of the unfair and extraordinary tactics of the minority of the investigating committee.
The candid public will learn with astonishment from the statement of the six Republican members who met in Chicago Tuesday that the evidence in the case "was never weighed and discussed in committee." This is literally startling. The so-called minority report is no report at all It is merely a snap judgment prompted by very small partisan politics The Madison report is of the same quality and kind.
New York Evening Post.
That there is great force in the criticism passed upon the action of the Democratic and "insurgent" contingent of the Ballinger investigating committee by the "regular" Republican members of it cannot be denied. While, as we have said, the conclusions announced by Representative Madison are such as impartial students of the evidence will generally approve, the method of procedure adopted by the minority, consisting of himself and the Democrats, is inconsistent with the idea of a judicially conducted inquiry by an unbiased committee.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Justice Deception

What keywords are associated?

Ballinger Case Investigating Committee Partisan Politics Republican Members Minority Report

What entities or persons were involved?

Secretary Ballinger Representative Madison

Where did it happen?

Chicago

Story Details

Key Persons

Secretary Ballinger Representative Madison

Location

Chicago

Story Details

Criticism of the Ballinger investigating committee's handling, where Republican members claim evidence was not weighed, calling the minority report a partisan snap judgment, while acknowledging force in critiques of the minority's procedure.

Are you sure?