Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Martinsburg Gazette
Story December 20, 1837

Martinsburg Gazette

Martinsburg, Berkeley County, West Virginia

What is this article about?

Negro Harry convicted in Romney Court of raping and attempting to murder 11-year-old Margaret Nelson; sentenced to hang on January 12. Victim testified after recovery. Case highlights risks of circumstantial evidence, as suspicion might have fallen on Mr. Robinson instead.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

To Be Hung.—Negro Harry was tried on Monday last by the Romney Court for rape, and an attempt to murder a white girl aged about 11 years—he was found guilty, and sentenced 'to be hung' on the 12th day of January next.

The little girl, whom he had so badly injured, and left lying on a stone pile in the woods, where her friends found her next day, with her skull fractured in three places, had so far recovered on Monday, as to be able to attend at the Court House, and give evidence against the black demon in human shape.

The evidence adduced upon the trial, was in substance, that the girl, Margaret Nelson, left her mother's dwelling to visit a neighbor, and on her return was accompanied by a Mr. Robinson, and a short distance from the place where she was found, Robinson separated from her, and took a road more direct to his own dwelling.

If the girl had been found dead, on whom would suspicion have rested? we answer, on Mr. Robinson. No one thought of the negro—Robinson was seen last with her, not far from the place where she was found. And alone upon the information furnished by the young lady, was the negro arrested.

The records of our criminal Courts have many melancholy instances of the innocent being condemned upon circumstantial evidence, as weak as this would have been—and though a conviction may not have been the result, yet suspicion and malice would have placed him in a delicate situation.

This case illustrates in some measure the necessity of observing caution and a strict adherence to that merciful rule which requires that ninety and nine guilty ones should escape, rather than one innocent man should suffer.—Maryland Advocate.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Story

What themes does it cover?

Crime Punishment Justice

What keywords are associated?

Rape Trial Attempted Murder Child Victim Circumstantial Evidence Court Conviction Racial Crime

What entities or persons were involved?

Negro Harry Margaret Nelson Mr. Robinson

Where did it happen?

Romney Court

Story Details

Key Persons

Negro Harry Margaret Nelson Mr. Robinson

Location

Romney Court

Event Date

Monday Last; 12th Day Of January Next

Story Details

Negro Harry tried and convicted for raping and attempting to murder 11-year-old Margaret Nelson, who testified after recovery from skull fractures; sentenced to hang on January 12. Evidence showed she was last seen with Mr. Robinson before the attack; case warns of circumstantial evidence risks.

Are you sure?