Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for New York Daily Tribune
Editorial November 17, 1856

New York Daily Tribune

New York, New York County, New York

What is this article about?

Editorial critiques The Union's defense of Buchanan's views on the Cincinnati Platform and Ostend Manifesto, agreeing on Cuba's potential annexation but questioning Democratic policy on Central America, citing Soulé's visit and slavery's reestablishment in Nicaragua.

Clipping

OCR Quality

88% Good

Full Text

The Union thus gives its explanation of the Cincinnati Platform and Mr. Buchanan's Ostend Manifesto: "The Government of the United States has never interfered, and we feel assured will never interfere, with the internal affairs of Mexico or Central America, for any other purpose than that of counteracting the intrigues and encroachments of foreign powers, and fostering their new born freedom. With respect to Cuba, the case is quite different; nor do we think it will injure the reputation of Mr. Buchanan or any other American statesman, to be suspected of a desire to emancipate that fine island from colonial vassalage, and (if such is the wish of the inhabitants) to admit as a member of this confederation. It is not fit that the key to the Gulf of Mexico should be in the hands of an enemy, or one who is the mere tool of our enemies. The North and West, equally with the South, are deeply interested in this question, which seems to be sleeping now, but which, we opine, will never die." No doubt The Union is right in what it says about Mr. Buchanan's views on Cuba, but we fear it is not so clear with regard to the "Democratic" policy respecting Central America. What does the official journal think of the late visit of Mr. Buchanan's friend and Ostend chum, Soulé, to that region, and the reestablishment of Slavery there in consequence? Does it mean to say that when the new negro-buying Republic of Nicaragua applies for admission to the American Union, Mr. Buchanan will repel the application?

What sub-type of article is it?

Foreign Affairs Imperialism Partisan Politics

What keywords are associated?

Ostend Manifesto Cincinnati Platform Cuba Annexation Central America Policy Slavery Nicaragua Buchanan Foreign Policy

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Buchanan Soulé The Union Nicaragua

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Critique Of Buchanan's Foreign Policy On Cuba And Central America

Stance / Tone

Critical Of Democratic Expansionism And Slavery In Central America

Key Figures

Mr. Buchanan Soulé The Union Nicaragua

Key Arguments

Us Should Not Interfere In Mexico Or Central America Except Against Foreign Powers Cuba Should Be Emancipated From Spain And Admitted To The Us Democratic Policy On Central America Unclear Given Soulé'S Actions Reestablishment Of Slavery In Nicaragua Contradicts Non Interference Claims Questions If Buchanan Would Admit Slave Holding Nicaragua To The Union

Are you sure?