Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Alexandria Gazette
Story August 28, 1849

Alexandria Gazette

Alexandria, Alexandria County, District Of Columbia

What is this article about?

An article defends General Taylor's awkward manners and lack of oratory skills, noting public acceptance of his style, and recounts Captain Hull's modest refusal to speechify at a Boston dinner after capturing the Guerriere in 1812.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Manners and Speech-making:
Some of the Opposition journals find it rare sport to criticise General Taylor's speeches and ridicule his manners. They say that he is awkward before strangers, and does not make a favorable impression. On this point there may well be a difference of opinion. Surely enough, he has not the manners of a dancing master, but it has been well said that he gave a reception to twenty thousand strangers at Buena Vista in a style that few dancing-masters could have equalled.
As to his speech-making, the people knew very well what kind of speeches General Taylor would make before they elected him President. Heaven has bestowed divers gifts on divers persons. It was not necessary for General Taylor to make long speeches, in order to gain the popular confidence: and that confidence will not be withdrawn because he fails to make long speeches.
When the chivalrous Hull broke the spell of England's supremacy on the ocean, by the capture of the Guerriere, on his return to port he was complimented by the citizens of Boston with a public dinner. The cloth being removed, after a few preliminary toasts came that to the honor of the captain: "Our gallant guest who has secured for himself a name and a praise among his countrymen, and added terror to the courtesy of his country's flag." The toast was drunk with enthusiasm, and then all was quiet.
A friend, sitting next to the gallant captain, said, "Sir, we are waiting for your speech." "A speech!" said the chivalrous but modest Hull, "I can't make one-I don't know how." A gentleman on the opposite side of the table exclaimed, audibly, "Sir, you are in for a speech. Don't you see that the president is waiting for your response to the toast?" The noble Tar rose up and said, "Mr. President, the gentlemen round me say that you and the other gentlemen are waiting for me to make a speech. Sir, I never made one in my life. I can't do it, sir. I don't know how, sir. By ---, I'd rather fight the battle over again than try it."
The rafters of Faneuil Hall were a little displaced by the truthful delicacy of the gallant captain: but we never heard that the newspapers of that day thought it a proper subject of ridicule, or that it impaired the well-earned honors of the chivalrous sailor.-Republic.

What sub-type of article is it?

Biography Historical Event Heroic Act

What themes does it cover?

Bravery Heroism Moral Virtue Triumph

What keywords are associated?

General Taylor Manners Criticism Speech Making Captain Hull Guerriere Capture Boston Dinner Modest Hero

What entities or persons were involved?

General Taylor Captain Hull

Where did it happen?

Buena Vista, Ocean, Boston, Faneuil Hall

Story Details

Key Persons

General Taylor Captain Hull

Location

Buena Vista, Ocean, Boston, Faneuil Hall

Story Details

Opposition criticizes Taylor's manners and speeches; defended by his Buena Vista reception and public knowledge of his style. Anecdote of Hull's modest refusal to speak at Boston dinner after Guerriere capture, preferring battle over oratory.

Are you sure?