Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Virginia Free Press
Story April 18, 1851

Virginia Free Press

Charles Town, Jefferson County, West Virginia

What is this article about?

Humorous frontier-era courtroom speech defending a man accused of stealing percussion caps, using vivid, absurd imagery of a sneaky nighttime theft from a sleeping family to argue innocence and plead for acquittal.

Clipping

OCR Quality

70% Good

Full Text

Gentlemen of the jury--can you for an instant conceive that my client here--a man moved a depredation in society [illegible] and esteem for his many supporters. Truly can you. I say for instance, who would be guilty of hooking a box of percussion caps? Rattle yourselves a feller fast asleep in his log cabin with his innocent wife and orphan children by his side--all nature hushed in deep repose, and nought to be heard but the muttering of the silent thunder, and hollering of frogs--then imagine to yourselves a fellow sneaking up to the door, like a despicable hyena, softly entering the dwelling of the peaceful and happy family, and in the most mendacious and dastardly manner, hooking a whole box of percussion caps. Gentlemen I will not, I cannot dwell upon the monstrosity of such a scene! My feelings turn from such a picture of moral turpitude, like a big woodchuck would turn from my dog Rose! I cannot for an instant harbor the idea that any man in these diggings, much less this ere man, could be guilty of committing an act of such rambunctious and unexampled desecration. And now gentlemen, after this ere brief view of the case, let me entreat you to make up your minds candidly and impartially, and give us such a verdict as we might reasonably expect from such an enlightened and intelligent body of our fellow-citizens, remembering that in the language of Nimrod who fell in the battle of Bunker Hill, it is better that ten guilty men escape, rather than one innocent one should suffer. Judge, give us a chaw of tobacco.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Story Deception Fraud Curiosity

What themes does it cover?

Crime Punishment Justice Deception

What keywords are associated?

Theft Trial Courtroom Speech Percussion Caps Humorous Defense Frontier Justice

What entities or persons were involved?

My Client

Where did it happen?

These Diggings

Story Details

Key Persons

My Client

Location

These Diggings

Story Details

A lawyer delivers a folksy, exaggerated closing argument defending his client against a charge of stealing a box of percussion caps, vividly describing the sneaky theft in a peaceful log cabin setting to emphasize its monstrous nature and implausibility, then urges the jury for an acquittal, misquoting a proverb attributed to Nimrod at Bunker Hill.

Are you sure?