Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Morning Herald
Story January 21, 1840

Morning Herald

New York, New York County, New York

What is this article about?

U.S. Navy controversy: Court of Inquiry recommends court martial for Capt. Elliott on charges by Lieut. Hunter et al., but Department, via Judge Advocate and Attorney General, decides against it, prompting officers to consider self-redress for insults.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Capt. Elliott and the Court Martial.—The Court of Inquiry, ordered to investigate certain charges alleged against Capt. Elliott, by Lieut. Charles G. Hunter, and others, adjourned some months since, reporting, that a Court Martial was necessary. Why that Court has not been ordered, is a matter of surprise to most of the officers of the U. S. Navy. If the Department found it necessary to order a Court of Inquiry for the purpose of investigating those charges, it certainly must have been the intention of the Department to be governed by the decision of that Court.

We have been informed that the Department, after receiving the report of the Court of Inquiry, forwarded the proceedings of that Court to Mr. Read, the Judge Advocate, with directions for him to frame charges, grounded upon those proceedings. He did so, and forwarded them to the Department; but the Department then thought it advisable to refer the matter to the Attorney General, by whom it was decided, that there was no ground for a Court Martial. If this is true—and the source from which it came, in connection with the fact of several most important witnesses being ordered to sea, places it almost beyond a doubt—there is nothing left for the subordinate officers of the Navy, but to protect themselves. They have been waiting anxiously for the result of this business, in order to determine what course to pursue; and hereafter, when an insult is offered, instead of appealing to the Department, where no redress is to be obtained, they will take redress into their own hands—it is the only course they can pursue—it is, under existing circumstances, the only alternative left them; and they will be perfectly justifiable in striking to the earth those dastards who, sheltering themselves under the cloak of rank, take that opportunity to insult and degrade those placed under their command.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Justice Crime Punishment

What keywords are associated?

Navy Court Martial Elliott Charges Military Justice Officer Protection

What entities or persons were involved?

Capt. Elliott Lieut. Charles G. Hunter Mr. Read Attorney General

Where did it happen?

U. S. Navy

Story Details

Key Persons

Capt. Elliott Lieut. Charles G. Hunter Mr. Read Attorney General

Location

U. S. Navy

Event Date

Some Months Since

Story Details

A Court of Inquiry investigated charges against Capt. Elliott by Lieut. Hunter and others, recommending a Court Martial. The Department delayed ordering it, referred proceedings to Judge Advocate Read who framed charges, then to the Attorney General who decided no grounds existed. Navy officers, feeling unprotected, may resort to self-redress against insults from superiors.

Are you sure?