Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Alexandria Gazette
Editorial September 18, 1841

Alexandria Gazette

Alexandria, Alexandria County, District Of Columbia

What is this article about?

Editorial contrasts British and American government actions: British Ministry resigns due to popular opposition, while American Cabinet resigns against the President's will despite public support, emphasizing constitutional differences.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

The difference between the action of our government and that of Great Britain—much as we are in the habit of comparing them—was never more strongly manifested than it has been by recent events. The British Ministry have before this time gone out of office in consequence of finding themselves in opposition to the will of the people; the American Ministry have resigned because they find themselves in opposition to the Executive, with four-fifths of the people with them. Our Cabinet is dissolved voluntarily rather than to act counter to the expressed opinions of the National representatives—the British Cabinet is involuntarily dissolved rather than act in accordance with the wishes of the National legislature. In both cases the popular will drives the Ministry out of office, but in our case the constitutional advisers of the Chief Magistrate leave their places with the people and against the President; while Lord Melbourne and Lord John Russell leave theirs with the good will of the Sovereign, and in consequence of the ill will of Parliament—N. Y. Courier.

What sub-type of article is it?

Constitutional Partisan Politics

What keywords are associated?

Government Comparison Cabinet Resignation British Ministry American Executive Constitutional Differences Popular Will

What entities or persons were involved?

British Ministry American Ministry Lord Melbourne Lord John Russell President Sovereign Parliament National Representatives

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Differences In British And American Ministerial Resignations

Stance / Tone

Favorable To American Constitutional Practice

Key Figures

British Ministry American Ministry Lord Melbourne Lord John Russell President Sovereign Parliament National Representatives

Key Arguments

British Ministry Resigns Due To Opposition From The People American Cabinet Resigns Due To Opposition From The Executive Despite Public Support Us Cabinet Acts With The People Against The President Uk Cabinet Acts With Sovereign Against Parliament Popular Will Drives Both Ministries Out Of Office

Are you sure?