Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The New York Journal, And Daily Patriotic Register
Letter to Editor January 15, 1788

The New York Journal, And Daily Patriotic Register

New York, New York County, New York

What is this article about?

A society of Pennsylvania citizens, via the Carlisle Gazette, addresses the Minority of the State Convention, vehemently opposing the proposed Federal Constitution as a path to aristocracy and slavery, praising the Minority's dissent and warning of civil discord if adopted.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

From the Carlisle Gazette.

Messrs. Printers,

By inserting the following in your useful Gazette, you will oblige a number of your constant readers.

An Address to the Minority of the State Convention of Pennsylvania.

THE history of mankind is pregnant with frequent, bloody and almost imperceptible transitions from freedom to slavery. Rome, after she had been long distracted by the fury of the Patrician and Plebeian parties, at length found herself reduced to the most abject slavery under a Nero, a Caligula, &c. The successive convulsions, which happened at Rome, were the immediate consequence of the aspiring ambition of a few great men, and the very organization and construction of the government itself. The republic of Venice, by the progressive and almost imperceptible encroachments of the nobles, has at length degenerated into an odious and permanent aristocracy. This we are convinced by indubitable demonstration, will be the final consequence of the proposed Federal Constitution; and because we prize the felicity and freedom of our posterity equally with our own, we esteem it our indispensable duty to oppose it with that determined resolution and spirit that becomes freemen. That fire for liberty which was kindled in every breast during the late glorious contention, though in a latent state, will be easily rekindled; and upon the contact of a very spark will devour by its direful explosion, not only the enemies of liberty, but both parties promiscuously. Discontent, indignation and revenge, already begins to be visible in every patriotic countenance; and civil discord already raises her sneaky head: and we are well convinced that nothing less than a total recantation and annihilation of the proposed aristocratic delusion will appease the insulted and enraged defenders of liberty. If the lazy and great wish to ride, they may lay it down as an indubitable position or axiom, that the people of America will make very refractory and restiff backneys. Although the designing and artful federalists have effected their schemes so far as to have the constitution adopted in this state by surprize, notwithstanding the people are pretty generally convinced of their delusion, and little less than the lives of their betrayers will satiate their revenge. Not even the authority of the clergy, who seem generally to have been a set of men decidedly opposed to popular freedom, can give sanction to such a government. The people of America understand their rights better than, by adopting such a constitution, to rivet the fetters of slavery; or to sacrifice their liberty at the shrine of aristocracy or arbitrary government. We, the subscribers, are a society united for the express purpose of reciprocal or mutual improvement; we meet once a week, and political matters are frequently the subjects of litigation and debate. We have read and endeavoured fully to comprehend the proposed federal constitution; and also the arguments for and against it; and after mature deliberation, we unanimously acquiesce with, and cordially thank you the Minority in the late State Convention:

First, for your patriotic and spirited endeavours to support the drooping cause of liberty and rights of your constituents: Secondly, for your integrity and firmness in stemming the torrent of popular clamour, insult and flattery: Thirdly, for your unanswerable, solid and well founded arguments and reasons of dissent: Lastly, we rejoice to think that your names will shine illustriously in the page of history, and will be read with honor and grateful remembrance in the annals of fame, while the names of the majority, and their ignorant tools will be spurned and execrated by the succeeding generations as the pillars of slavery, and despotism.

James M'Gormick,
David Boyd,
William Gelston,
James Irvin,
Andrew Irvin,
William Carothers, senior.
William Adams,
William Carothers, junior,
John Douglas,
Archibald Hamilton,
Joseph Junkin,
John Clendinen,
Thomas Henderson,
Robert Bell,
John Junkin,
James Bell,
Thomas Atchley
William Irvin,
William Douglas,
John Walker,
William Greason
David Walker,
Jonathan Walker,
John Buchanan,
Francis M'Guire,
John Armstrong,
Benj. Junkin,
John Carothers, junior,
James Fleming,
Thomas Carothers.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Political Provocative

What themes does it cover?

Constitutional Rights Politics

What keywords are associated?

Federal Constitution Opposition Pennsylvania Convention Minority Dissent Liberty Aristocracy Civil Discord Historical Precedents

What entities or persons were involved?

James M'gormick, David Boyd, William Gelston, James Irvin, Andrew Irvin, William Carothers, Senior, William Adams, William Carothers, Junior, John Douglas, Archibald Hamilton, Joseph Junkin, John Clendinen, Thomas Henderson, Robert Bell, John Junkin, James Bell, Thomas Atchley, William Irvin, William Douglas, John Walker, William Greason, David Walker, Jonathan Walker, John Buchanan, Francis M'guire, John Armstrong, Benj. Junkin, John Carothers, Junior, James Fleming, Thomas Carothers Messrs. Printers; An Address To The Minority Of The State Convention Of Pennsylvania

Letter to Editor Details

Author

James M'gormick, David Boyd, William Gelston, James Irvin, Andrew Irvin, William Carothers, Senior, William Adams, William Carothers, Junior, John Douglas, Archibald Hamilton, Joseph Junkin, John Clendinen, Thomas Henderson, Robert Bell, John Junkin, James Bell, Thomas Atchley, William Irvin, William Douglas, John Walker, William Greason, David Walker, Jonathan Walker, John Buchanan, Francis M'guire, John Armstrong, Benj. Junkin, John Carothers, Junior, James Fleming, Thomas Carothers

Recipient

Messrs. Printers; An Address To The Minority Of The State Convention Of Pennsylvania

Main Argument

the proposed federal constitution will lead to aristocracy and slavery like historical examples of rome and venice; the signatories oppose it firmly, praise the minority's dissent, and warn of civil discord and revenge if adopted.

Notable Details

References To Roman History Under Nero And Caligula Venetian Aristocracy As Cautionary Tale Fire For Liberty Rekindled Civil Discord And Revenge Against Betrayers Clergy Opposed To Popular Freedom Society For Mutual Improvement Debating Politics

Are you sure?