Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Alexandria Daily Advertiser
Domestic News December 28, 1805

Alexandria Daily Advertiser

Alexandria, Virginia

What is this article about?

In the U.S. House of Representatives on December 26, a debate arose over a resolution to award William Eaton a gold medal for capturing Derne, with Messrs. Clay and Randolph arguing it was disproportionate to the achievement and suggesting a vote of thanks instead.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Proceedings of Congress Taken for the "Alexandria Daily Advertiser."

NINTH CONGRESS.

OF THE

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES:

Thursday, December 26.

Mr. Bidwell called for the resolution, respecting a reward to WILLIAM EATON, Esq.

This produced a long, and animated debate.

It was began by Mr. J. Clay; who said, that it was very far from his intention, to depreciate the merits of Mr. Eaton; but he could not reconcile it to his mind; that the taking of such a place of Derne, in which about a dozen Americans assisted, was worthy of the high and honorable reward of a Gold Medal. He observed that such rewards were only voted on the most important occasions, and he mentioned such an instance as the capture of York Town.

Mr. J. Randolph, concurred with the last speaker. He too was of opinion that the reward should be in proportion to the services rendered. He did not personally know the gentleman in question, but he thought that he would be better gratified by a vote of thanks. He did not think, this a case, where a gold medal should be voted. Three times only, during the revolutionary war with Great Britain, this had been done. Once on account of the victory of Saratoga: a second time on the capture of the English Army under Lord Cornwallis; and again, on that most important and sublime occasion, the resignation of the commander in chief of his commission to Congress, on a glorious peace. There is, continued Mr. Randolph, a Bathos in politics, as well as in poetry, and in both we may go too far. Shall we in this instance pass a vote similar to that on those great occasions? or a mere skirmish, between an handful of Americans, and a parcel of half naked barbarians!- The expression of the unanimous vote of thanks from the House, would be thought to be more satisfactory, than the reward now in contemplation; and would fully remunerate the gentleman for his service.

(This interesting debate will be continued, but the time at present, will not allow more, previous to the departure of the mail.

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics

What keywords are associated?

Congress Debate William Eaton Derne Capture Gold Medal Reward Vote Of Thanks

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Bidwell William Eaton, Esq. Mr. J. Clay Mr. J. Randolph

Where did it happen?

United States House Of Representatives

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

United States House Of Representatives

Event Date

Thursday, December 26.

Key Persons

Mr. Bidwell William Eaton, Esq. Mr. J. Clay Mr. J. Randolph

Outcome

debate ongoing; resolution for gold medal reward contested in favor of a vote of thanks.

Event Details

Mr. Bidwell called for the resolution respecting a reward to William Eaton for the capture of Derne. Mr. J. Clay argued against a gold medal, citing its rarity for major events like Yorktown. Mr. J. Randolph agreed, suggesting a vote of thanks instead, comparing it unfavorably to Revolutionary War honors and calling the action a skirmish.

Are you sure?