Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Davenport Gazette
Editorial August 17, 1848

The Davenport Gazette

Davenport, Scott County, Iowa

What is this article about?

The Haverhill Gazette editor defends against accusations of dishonesty for initially opposing Gen. Taylor's nomination but now supporting him over Cass, using a simile comparing it to refusing a flawed ship but not sinking to a mud-scow alternative.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

AN APT ILLUSTRATION.

The editor of the Haverhill (Mass.) Gazette, in a dignified reply to an insulting communication, abusing him for supporting Gen. Taylor, forcibly illustrates the position of the 'disaffected Whigs' by a striking simile. He says:--

'Our writings against the nomination of Taylor are quoted with all imaginable absurdity, as if they pledged us to oppose his election after the question is reduced to him or Cass. We are accused of dishonesty, and asked why we do not go to 'picking pockets for a living, if we cannot afford to be a man?' We can afford to be a man, but not to be an idiot, and feel that we can no more justly be charged with dishonesty or inconsistency than the man who should refuse to take passage across the ocean in a packet ship because he had objected for some reason to that particular ship being put upon the line. According to these wise casuists, he should throw himself into a mud-scow, without the slightest regard to its capacity of ever reaching the destined shore, and do all in his power, by torpedoes, fireballs and false lights, to wreck the ship to which he has objected.'

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics

What keywords are associated?

Disaffected Whigs Taylor Nomination Cass Election Political Inconsistency Whig Support

What entities or persons were involved?

Gen. Taylor Cass Haverhill Gazette Editor Disaffected Whigs

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Defense Against Accusations Of Inconsistency In Supporting Taylor Over Cass

Stance / Tone

Defensive And Illustrative Of Whig Position

Key Figures

Gen. Taylor Cass Haverhill Gazette Editor Disaffected Whigs

Key Arguments

Initial Opposition To Taylor's Nomination Does Not Pledge Opposition To His Election Against Cass Accusations Of Dishonesty Are Absurd, Like Refusing A Flawed Ship But Not Choosing A Worse Alternative True Inconsistency Would Be Sabotaging The Better Option To Support An Inferior One

Are you sure?