Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Virginia Argus
Editorial September 5, 1811

Virginia Argus

Richmond, Virginia

What is this article about?

The Baltimore American editorial exposes a forged treaty between the US and France, published in Philadelphia's True American, as a Federalist fabrication designed to aid their cause in the upcoming senatorial election. It ridicules the treaty's implausible articles surrendering US property to Napoleon, partitioning British provinces, and admitting the US to the Rhenish confederacy.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

A treaty, said by federalists to have been taken to France by Mr. Barlow, has recently made its appearance in the True American of Philadelphia. The first article of it surrenders to Napoleon the whole of the mercantile property sequestrated and confiscated under the French edicts. Another article provides that if France and America should think proper to take possession of the British provinces of Canada and Nova Scotia, they shall be disposed of according to the pleasure of "his imperial majesty." And according to another article, the United States are to be admitted into the Rhenish confederacy as soon as it may suit the convenience of the French ruler?

This treaty, so palpable a fabrication is it, has not even been noticed by the other federal papers of Philadelphia. It was unquestionably manufactured in Baltimore, and designed to subserve the success of the federal cause at the approaching senatorial election in this state. Of this fact we have very little doubt. The two federal papers in town have seized upon it in an instant, as an honorable weapon with which to fight the republicans.

The very first article is the strongest presumptive proof of its falsehood. Federalists will not charge administration with adopting measures which would in a moment prostrate their own popularity and standing with the people; but certainly, if Mr. Madison is so very anxious to be re-elected, as they assert he is, he would never have agreed to such an article in a treaty with France, much less would he have proposed it.

The article respecting the British provinces is a very improbable one. It is not likely that the U. States would go to the expense of blood and treasure to subdue the American provinces for a foreign power to give them to another.

As to the article proposing our admission into the confederation of the Rhine, it is the most ridiculous and wretched piece of artifice of which we ever heard. Has any man the sagacity to perceive why and wherefore America should desire to be a member of the League of the Rhine? Can any man point out the reason why Bonaparte should desire it? What are the objects of that league? Simply, to keep the German princes in order, and to overawe Russia and the other northern powers. Could America be of any service in promoting these objects? Unquestionably not.

But the concluding article of this forged treaty is truly delectable. It provides for the publication of the instrument in both English and French, but makes it the duty of the high contracting parties to consider it as having been originally written in the French language.

If such be the means which federalism uses to climb to power; if forgery, falsehood, and depravity of this kind are the only pillars by which their expiring hopes are to be supported, then, alas! deplorable must be their condition.

Baltimore American.

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics Foreign Affairs

What keywords are associated?

Forged Treaty Federalists Napoleon Madison Senatorial Election France British Provinces Rhenish Confederacy Partisan Fabrication

What entities or persons were involved?

Federalists Mr. Barlow Napoleon Mr. Madison Republicans Bonaparte Baltimore American True American Of Philadelphia

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Debunking Forged Us France Treaty For Electioneering

Stance / Tone

Anti Federalist Accusation Of Forgery And Falsehood

Key Figures

Federalists Mr. Barlow Napoleon Mr. Madison Republicans Bonaparte Baltimore American True American Of Philadelphia

Key Arguments

The Treaty Is A Palpable Fabrication Manufactured In Baltimore To Aid Federalists In The Senatorial Election. It Has Not Been Noticed By Other Federal Papers, Indicating Its Falsehood. The First Article Surrendering Us Property To Napoleon Is Implausible And Would Harm Administration's Popularity. The Article On Partitioning British Provinces Is Improbable As The Us Would Not Conquer For A Foreign Power. Admission To The Rhenish Confederacy Is Ridiculous And Serves No Purpose For Either America Or France. The Concluding Article On Language Is A Poor Artifice. Federalism Relies On Forgery And Depravity To Gain Power.

Are you sure?