Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Constitutional Whig
Letter to Editor September 3, 1828

Constitutional Whig

Richmond, Virginia

What is this article about?

A letter to 'Manlius' criticizes the Enquirer's editors for using Dr. Watkins' letter to undermine Judge Williams' statement on a ball event, while withholding information that Watkins lacks credibility in Albemarle County, transmitted by a neutral source.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

COMMUNICATED FOR THE WHIG.

A CARD TO "MANLIUS."

You will, I doubt not sir, be a little startled when I tell you, that, whilst the Editors of the Enquirer were penning their remarks on your communication in their paper of the 22nd instant, in which they say, in relation to the transactions of the Ball, "the letter of Dr. Watkins, exposes this part of Judge Williams' statement, and strips it of all its force," they were in possession, (and had been ten or twelve days,) of a communication, forwarded to them in consequence of, and immediately after the publication of the said letter in the Virginia Advocate, informing them and the public, that Dr. Watkins had, in the estimation of the people of this county (Albemarle) generally, forfeited all pretensions whatever to credibility, or the character of a gentleman: thus using his name, and his letter, for political effect, whilst holding in their hands, and withholding from the public, evidence of the entire worthlessness of both—transmitted to them by a responsible person, in his own proper name—a person who has never, as they were informed, mingled in the unhappy controversy which is now agitating the country to its center—who had no idea of criminating General Jackson, or defending Judge Williams, but who was reluctantly impelled, by a strict sense of duty, to caution his fellow-citizens at a distance against testimony not entitled to credibility.

Leaving the matter to yourself, and the people,

I am &c. &c.

A FRIEND TO JUSTICE

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Political Provocative

What themes does it cover?

Politics Press Freedom Morality

What keywords are associated?

Political Controversy Dr Watkins Credibility Albemarle County Enquirer Editors Judge Williams General Jackson Press Withholding Virginia Advocate

What entities or persons were involved?

A Friend To Justice Manlius.

Letter to Editor Details

Author

A Friend To Justice

Recipient

Manlius.

Main Argument

the enquirer's editors hypocritically used dr. watkins' letter to discredit judge williams while suppressing evidence of watkins' forfeited credibility in albemarle county, provided by a neutral source, for political effect in the ongoing controversy involving general jackson.

Notable Details

Reference To Enquirer's Remarks On 22nd Instant Transactions Of The Ball Publication In Virginia Advocate Withholding Communication For 10 12 Days Albemarle County Estimation Of Dr. Watkins Neutral Source Not Involved In Controversy Caution Against Unreliable Testimony

Are you sure?