Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
January 6, 1896
Orleans County Monitor
Barton, Orleans County, Vermont
What is this article about?
Editorial denounces authorized flogging of girls as barbaric, calls on Home Secretary to oppose it, notes caning in elementary schools per Mr. Riley, and contrasts with outdated views of Locke and Johnson, sourced from London News.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
Flogging Girls.
The authorized flogging of little girls or big girls is a piece of barbarism which, now that the subject has been definitely raised, will receive, we trust, no countenance from the home secretary. Mr. Riley says that girls in the elementary schools are caned, a bit of information which we commend to the immediate notice of Sir John Gorst. The public of London has outgrown the days of Mother Brownrigg, and Mother Brownrigg, as the Newgate "Calendar" informs us, was not sustained by judge, jury, public opinion or Jack Ketch in her theories and her practice as to the castigation of girls. There were philosophers, to be sure, who approved of the whipping of girls. Locke did, for one, and so did Dr. Johnson. Locke approved of a mother who whipped her little daughter nine times in order to compel the child to confess some error, and Johnson commended a mother who whipped her child in the interest of future truthfulness because the girl had said she came in through one door, when, in fact, she had come in through another. But those were days when children were supposed to be born only that they might be birched as far as possible out of their share of original sin. Women were publicly flogged at the cart's tail in the days of Locke and Johnson--and, of course, in the interest of discipline and order and morals. We cannot go back to those days, and any serious and public attempt to get back to them would be an absurdity as well as an outrage.--London News.
The authorized flogging of little girls or big girls is a piece of barbarism which, now that the subject has been definitely raised, will receive, we trust, no countenance from the home secretary. Mr. Riley says that girls in the elementary schools are caned, a bit of information which we commend to the immediate notice of Sir John Gorst. The public of London has outgrown the days of Mother Brownrigg, and Mother Brownrigg, as the Newgate "Calendar" informs us, was not sustained by judge, jury, public opinion or Jack Ketch in her theories and her practice as to the castigation of girls. There were philosophers, to be sure, who approved of the whipping of girls. Locke did, for one, and so did Dr. Johnson. Locke approved of a mother who whipped her little daughter nine times in order to compel the child to confess some error, and Johnson commended a mother who whipped her child in the interest of future truthfulness because the girl had said she came in through one door, when, in fact, she had come in through another. But those were days when children were supposed to be born only that they might be birched as far as possible out of their share of original sin. Women were publicly flogged at the cart's tail in the days of Locke and Johnson--and, of course, in the interest of discipline and order and morals. We cannot go back to those days, and any serious and public attempt to get back to them would be an absurdity as well as an outrage.--London News.
What sub-type of article is it?
Social Reform
Education
Crime Or Punishment
What keywords are associated?
Flogging Girls
Child Punishment
School Caning
Social Barbarism
Historical Reform
What entities or persons were involved?
Mr. Riley
Sir John Gorst
Home Secretary
Mother Brownrigg
Locke
Dr. Johnson
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Opposition To Flogging Girls
Stance / Tone
Strongly Against Flogging As Barbarism
Key Figures
Mr. Riley
Sir John Gorst
Home Secretary
Mother Brownrigg
Locke
Dr. Johnson
Key Arguments
Flogging Of Girls Is Barbarism That Should Receive No Support From Authorities
Girls In Elementary Schools Are Caned, As Reported By Mr. Riley
Public Has Outgrown Practices Like Those Of Mother Brownrigg
Historical Philosophers Like Locke And Johnson Approved Of Whipping Girls, But Those Views Are Outdated
Society Cannot Return To Days Of Public Flogging Of Women And Children