Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Gold Hill Daily News
Domestic News January 28, 1882

Gold Hill Daily News

Gold Hill, Storey County, Nevada

What is this article about?

A letter from J.A. Garfield dated July 21, 1880, to Hon. Alfred E. Lee refutes assertions that Garfield changed his opinion on the Fitz-John Porter court-martial case. Garfield criticizes proposals to annul the 16-year-old sentence, viewing it as extreme party passion condemning the original court and President Lincoln.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

A recent effort to manufacture capital in the interest of Fitz-John Porter was an assertion that the late President Garfield had changed his opinion with regard to the matter. That the assertion was false, the following letter clearly shows:

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, U. S.,
WASHINGTON, D. C., July 21, 1880.

Hon. Alfred E. Lee, U. S. Consul General, Frankfort-on-the-Main—My Dear Sir: Accept my thanks for your very interesting letter of the 2d instant in reference to the Fitz-John Porter case. The facts you relate are so entirely in accordance with my own understanding of the case that I shall be glad to make use of them in case I speak on the subject. It would add force to the case if you are willing that your name should be used, but of course I would not do this without your consent. Any other memorandum you may have, or are pleased to make, will be received with thanks. The Schofield Board have recommended, and the House Committee on Military Affairs have adopted, the astounding proposition to pass a law annulling and setting aside as void the lawful sentence of a court-martial executed more than sixteen years ago. Of course they thereby virtually condemn the court and President Lincoln. It seems to me the very extreme to which party passion can go. They will never pass the bill without such review of history as will enlighten the people afresh on the most disgraceful portion of our military history. Thanking you again for your letter, I am very truly yours,

J. A. GARFIELD.

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics Military Legal Or Court

What keywords are associated?

Fitz John Porter Court Martial Garfield Letter Schofield Board Military Affairs Annul Sentence

What entities or persons were involved?

J. A. Garfield Fitz John Porter Alfred E. Lee President Lincoln

Where did it happen?

Washington, D. C.

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

Washington, D. C.

Event Date

1880 07 21

Key Persons

J. A. Garfield Fitz John Porter Alfred E. Lee President Lincoln

Outcome

refutation of claim that garfield changed opinion; criticism of proposal to annul court-martial sentence.

Event Details

Letter from J.A. Garfield thanking Alfred E. Lee for information on Fitz-John Porter case, agreeing with facts provided, and criticizing Schofield Board and House Committee on Military Affairs for recommending a law to annul a 16-year-old court-martial sentence, seeing it as condemning the court and Lincoln due to party passion.

Are you sure?