Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Daily National Democrat
Editorial January 13, 1861

Daily National Democrat

Marysville, Yuba County, California

What is this article about?

An editorial endorses vigilante killings to defend women's honor over legal processes, quoting the Dutch Flat Inquirer on the San Francisco slaying of Newell by Mr. Smith, praising such acts as moral duty.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

The Higher Law.

Commenting on the killing of Newell, at San Francisco, the Dutch Flat Inquirer says:

There is a higher law than the lex scripta—the law of public opinion—and thank God, in this land that voice rises high and mighty, and proclaims him innocent who, in vindication of the honor and fame of his wife, mother, sister or daughter,—with his manly arm slays the traducer of their honor. Let not the sons of California appeal to the courts for redress, but, like men, punish the vile slanderer of female virtue with the knife or the gun. Such cowardly, contemptible wretches should not cumber the earth, and he who rids society of their presence, performs an act of common good, and is worthy of all commendation. Let husbands, fathers and brothers do their duty as jurors by acquitting all such, and the disgraceful slanders will die unuttered in the throats of cowards, for fear the craven heart from whence it would have emanated would be pierced by the steel of retributive and avenging justice.

The above thoughts have been suggested by the late homicide in San Francisco, and if the reports which we have received of the unfortunate affair are correct, Mr. Smith did no more than he was justified in doing. We regret the occurrence, but honor the husband and father.

What sub-type of article is it?

Moral Or Religious Crime Or Punishment

What keywords are associated?

Higher Law Public Opinion Family Honor Vigilante Justice Female Virtue Slander Punishment

What entities or persons were involved?

Newell Mr. Smith Dutch Flat Inquirer San Francisco

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Justification Of Vigilante Justice For Defending Female Honor

Stance / Tone

Strongly Supportive Of Extralegal Punishment For Slanderers

Key Figures

Newell Mr. Smith Dutch Flat Inquirer San Francisco

Key Arguments

Higher Law Of Public Opinion Justifies Killing Those Who Slander Women's Honor Sons Of California Should Punish Slanderers With Knife Or Gun Rather Than Courts Such Killers Perform An Act Of Common Good And Deserve Commendation Jurors Should Acquit Husbands, Fathers, And Brothers Who Avenge Family Honor This Will Deter Slanders Out Of Fear Of Retributive Justice Mr. Smith Was Justified In The San Francisco Homicide

Are you sure?