Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Alexandria Daily Advertiser
Domestic News April 21, 1808

Alexandria Daily Advertiser

Alexandria, Virginia

What is this article about?

Governor James Sullivan of Massachusetts publishes a response to Senator Timothy Pickering's letter, refusing to act as the official channel to communicate it to the state legislature, arguing it is not his constitutional duty. The letter criticizes Pickering's claim and returns the document unread beyond the first page.

Merged-components note: The official letter from Governor Sullivan is published immediately following and as part of the domestic news report on the reception of Colonel Pickering's letter; merging for coherence as a single news item on political correspondence.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

To satisfy the curiosity of those, who may wish to know the manner in which col. Pickering's letter was received by the governor of Massachusetts, we publish the following from under his own hand and seal. In publishing this, we shall only indulge in a single remark. If it be true, as the governor states, that, on reading the first page of the letter, he closed the manuscript, and wrote his peevish answer to colonel Pickering, he exhibited a petulance of disposition, a deficiency of candor, a want of common decorum, and a destitution of dignity of character extremely derogatory to the high and distinguished office he fills. If there is a decent man in that state, who is a friend and admirer of the governor, his face must be crimsoned with the blush of mortification and chagrin.

(N. Y. Spec.)
OFFICIAL.
Boston, March 3.

SIR,

I YESTERDAY received your letter consisting of six sheets, dated the 7th ultimo. My pressing calls in public concerns would not allow me to attempt to read it until late last evening. Before I had gone through the first page, I was surprised by your novel and extraordinary claim upon me, as governor of the commonwealth, expressed in these words— "I now address it (meaning your letter) to you, sir, as the proper organ of communication." Had this been a request to have communicated your letter to the legislature of this commonwealth, as a favor to you, I should have continued to read until from its contents I became satisfied, whether I ought, or ought not to grant it: but on finding it to be a new and unexpected claim upon my official duty, I folded the letter instantly, in order to reflect upon its principles; I have not unfolded it since, and now return it to you by the mail.

You will recollect that the senate and house of representatives of this commonwealth, are visible, organic bodies: that the former has a president, and the latter a speaker; that both have clerks. You will also recollect that there is a secretary chosen by the two houses; that whatever is proper to be communicated to them, by you, may be communicated through one, or the other of these; but that the governor of the commonwealth is obliged ex officio, to communicate as governor, to the legislature, whatever member of congress shall please to address to him for that purpose, cannot be submitted to by me until I find it to be made my duty by the constitution of the commonwealth. You seem to found your claim in your being a senator of this state: I can discern no distinction in this respect, between members of the senate, and members of the house: all are representatives of the state, and all must have equal claims.

I am, sir, your very humble servant,
JAMES SULLIVAN.

Hon. Timothy Pickering, esq.
a senator from Massachusetts,
in the congress of the United States.

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics

What keywords are associated?

Governor Sullivan Pickering Letter Massachusetts Legislature Official Communication Political Dispute

What entities or persons were involved?

James Sullivan Timothy Pickering

Where did it happen?

Boston, Massachusetts

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

Boston, Massachusetts

Event Date

March 3

Key Persons

James Sullivan Timothy Pickering

Outcome

governor sullivan returns pickering's letter unread beyond the first page and refuses to forward it to the legislature, citing it as an unconstitutional demand on his office.

Event Details

Governor James Sullivan receives a letter from Senator Timothy Pickering dated the 7th ultimo, addressed to him as the proper organ of communication to the Massachusetts legislature. Sullivan stops reading after the first page, reflects on the claim, and returns the letter, explaining that he is not obligated to communicate congressional members' letters to the legislature unless required by the constitution. He notes proper channels exist through legislative officers.

Are you sure?