Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for National Gazette
Letter to Editor February 9, 1793

National Gazette

Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania

What is this article about?

A critical letter denouncing an orator from the Philadelphia militia, praised in volunteer toasts, for his poor performance and anti-republican stance during New Jersey's constitutional convention, where he unsuccessfully opposed direct popular election of senators. Signed Veritas on February 8, 1793.

Clipping

OCR Quality

92% Excellent

Full Text

Mr. FRENEAU,

AMONG the volunteer toasts of the officers of the Philadelphia militia, an orator is held forth who signalized himself wonderfully in New-Jersey. It was scarcely necessary to travel so far back for a specimen of his oratorial flourishes, for so lately as the sitting of the convention of this state for the formation of our present constitution, did he exhibit his prowess in the powers of the tribune. His talents had there a full opportunity for a display; they might have shone forth in defence of equal principles; but excepting on one or two trifling occasions, he never attempted to astonish the convention with the thunder of his declamation, or the lightning of his argument. I will do him justice—he strove to be sure, as far as his ingenuity and a certain cast of disposition would allow, to remove the power of appointing senators from the people to a body of electors! but in this attempt upon equality, upon the inherent, the unalienable rights of the people to appoint their own legislators, he was foiled by the genuine talents and republicanism of a Wilson and a Findley. His oratory on that day will never be obliterated from my memory; but for his own honor, as well as for the honor of principles which he professes, it would have been better that he had been born without a tongue. It is grating to hear a man commended for talents that he does not possess, and for principles which he is a stranger to—As a bon vivant he has peculiar merit, but as an orator and a statesman his station is very subordinate.

VERITAS.

Feb. 8, 1793.

What sub-type of article is it?

Satirical Political Provocative

What themes does it cover?

Politics Constitutional Rights

What keywords are associated?

Philadelphia Militia New Jersey Orator Constitutional Convention Senators Election Republican Principles Wilson Findley

What entities or persons were involved?

Veritas Mr. Freneau

Letter to Editor Details

Author

Veritas

Recipient

Mr. Freneau

Main Argument

the letter mocks an orator praised by philadelphia militia officers for his supposed talents, highlighting his failure to defend republican principles during the state constitutional convention, especially his unsuccessful push to deny the people direct election of senators.

Notable Details

References To Foiling By Wilson And Findley Critique Of Oratory As Lacking Thunder And Lightning Accusation Of Lacking True Talents And Principles

Are you sure?