Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
January 11, 1880
Daily Globe
Saint Paul, Ramsey County, Minnesota
What is this article about?
Critique of hanging as a barbaric, unreliable execution method, calling for scientific, prompt, and bloodless alternatives to avoid torture, sourced from British Medical Journal.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
Improved Methods of Execution.
It is not surprising that from time to time attention is recalled to the barbarous nature of the mode of executing the death penalty in this country. Hanging by the neck till the criminal is dead is obviously a relic of barbarism; it is the most primitive, the most various, the least prompt and uniform and certain of the modes of execution which have been or could be devised. If the object of an execution now-a-days be to insure the rapid and certain death of the criminal without any probability of intervening accident, delay or torture, hanging by a cord and trusting to the rough adjustment of weight and fall which the "eye and experience" of an ignorant hangman can afford, is the most fallible of methods, and must of necessity from time to time lead to painful scenes of torture. The garotillo is, perhaps, of all existing foreign methods of legal execution the most rapid and certain; but without proposing any one substitute for our own responsibility—whether the carbonic acid chamber, the massive electric discharge, or any other method—it is certain that any scientific man or commission could very speedily devise a prompt and bloodless certain mode of execution which would be free from the clumsiness and uncertainty of hanging. The retention of this ancient relic of past barbarism is not creditable to our jurisprudence.—British Medical Journal.
It is not surprising that from time to time attention is recalled to the barbarous nature of the mode of executing the death penalty in this country. Hanging by the neck till the criminal is dead is obviously a relic of barbarism; it is the most primitive, the most various, the least prompt and uniform and certain of the modes of execution which have been or could be devised. If the object of an execution now-a-days be to insure the rapid and certain death of the criminal without any probability of intervening accident, delay or torture, hanging by a cord and trusting to the rough adjustment of weight and fall which the "eye and experience" of an ignorant hangman can afford, is the most fallible of methods, and must of necessity from time to time lead to painful scenes of torture. The garotillo is, perhaps, of all existing foreign methods of legal execution the most rapid and certain; but without proposing any one substitute for our own responsibility—whether the carbonic acid chamber, the massive electric discharge, or any other method—it is certain that any scientific man or commission could very speedily devise a prompt and bloodless certain mode of execution which would be free from the clumsiness and uncertainty of hanging. The retention of this ancient relic of past barbarism is not creditable to our jurisprudence.—British Medical Journal.
What sub-type of article is it?
Crime Or Punishment
What keywords are associated?
Execution Methods
Capital Punishment
Hanging Reform
Humane Execution
Penal Reform
What entities or persons were involved?
British Medical Journal
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Reform Of Execution Methods
Stance / Tone
Critical Of Hanging, Advocating Humane Alternatives
Key Figures
British Medical Journal
Key Arguments
Hanging By The Neck Is A Barbaric Relic, Primitive, Variable, And Unreliable
It Risks Accidents, Delays, Or Torture Due To Inexact Adjustments
Garotillo Is A Rapid Foreign Method, But Scientific Alternatives Like Carbonic Acid Chamber Or Electric Discharge Could Be Devised
Retention Of Hanging Discredits Modern Jurisprudence