Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Weekly National Intelligencer
Domestic News May 10, 1851

Weekly National Intelligencer

Washington, District Of Columbia

What is this article about?

The Newark Daily Advertiser comments on a recent polite but unintelligible debate in the New York Christian Enquirer between Mr. Henry James and the editor, now concluded without resolution.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

SHARP AS A RAZOR. We have not had the advantage of seeing any part of the "polite discussion" referred to in the following paragraph from the Newark Daily Advertiser, (distinguished, by the way, by the excellence of its own leading articles,) but we should be very unwilling to fall into hands which manage so dexterously the keenest weapons of criticism:

"Utility of Discussion. There has been agitated for some weeks past, in the columns of the Christian Enquirer, of New York, a very polite discussion between Mr. Henry James and the Editor of that paper, which wants only one ingredient to make it one of the most interesting now carried on. The feature we allude to is intelligibility. We are gradually borne along upon a current of smooth, decorous words, from one stopping-place to another, seeming to have now and then a sort of glimpse of the shore. But it is a deception, after all. The reader is in fact far out of soundings, and nothing is in sight but a heavy bank of fog on every side. It is not certain that if any thing were visible it would be worth seeing; but we are sure every reader of that excellent journal will be glad to be relieved from the necessity of straining his eyes 'to see what is not to be seen.' This is now happily accomplished, and the debate is at length closed, without, however, coming to any conclusion."

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics

What keywords are associated?

Henry James Christian Enquirer Polite Discussion Utility Of Discussion Newark Daily Advertiser

What entities or persons were involved?

Henry James Editor Of The Christian Enquirer

Where did it happen?

New York

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

New York

Event Date

Some Weeks Past

Key Persons

Henry James Editor Of The Christian Enquirer

Outcome

debate closed without conclusion

Event Details

A polite discussion on the utility of discussion between Mr. Henry James and the Editor of the Christian Enquirer, described as lacking intelligibility and carried on in a fog of decorous words, now concluded.

Are you sure?