Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The New Orleans Bulletin
Editorial April 6, 1875

The New Orleans Bulletin

New Orleans, Orleans County, Louisiana

What is this article about?

The editorial examines the debate in England to reinstate flogging for crimes like wife-beating and garroting, opposing Mr. Bright's arguments against it amid growing public support. It finds the proposal attractive and suggests it could address similar brutal offenses in America, as seen recently in Chicago and Brooklyn.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Flogging as a punishment has not passed out of history. Kindergarten ideas of civilization have brought it into disrepute; but it is still a serious question whether brutality cannot be most effectually dealt with by the lash, and whether those classes of society which persist in taking the physical view of humanity cannot be best instructed by a vigorous application of their own principles. The subject is now being widely discussed in England, in connection with a proposition to restore flogging on the roll of British punishments for such offenses as wife-beating and garroting. Mr. Bright has just written a letter opposing the idea; but it is said that his arguments run counter to a fast-growing public opinion. There is, indeed, a certain attractiveness in the suggestion. It might provide a cure for flagrant wrongs in America, such as have recently been conspicuously illustrated both in Chicago and Brooklyn.-Chicago Tribune, April 1st.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Or Punishment

What keywords are associated?

Flogging Punishment Wife Beating Garroting Brutality Public Opinion Mr. Bright

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Bright Chicago Tribune

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Restoration Of Flogging For Violent Crimes

Stance / Tone

Supportive Of Flogging's Potential Effectiveness

Key Figures

Mr. Bright Chicago Tribune

Key Arguments

Flogging Effectively Counters Brutality By Applying Physical Principles To Offenders Growing Public Opinion In England Favors Restoring Flogging For Wife Beating And Garroting Mr. Bright's Opposition Contradicts Public Sentiment Flogging Could Remedy Similar Violent Offenses In America, As In Chicago And Brooklyn

Are you sure?