Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Constitutional Whig
Editorial December 29, 1827

Constitutional Whig

Richmond, Virginia

What is this article about?

An editorial argues that Virginia slavery is benevolent, citing a runaway slave's voluntary return from Pennsylvania as proof that slaves prefer its comforts to the responsibilities of freedom. It claims Virginia slaves enjoy more solid comfort than free laborers elsewhere and advocates abolition only to relieve the burdens on masters and the state, not to improve slaves' conditions.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Slavery in Virginia.—In the county of Goochland, a negro man during the last summer, ran away from his owner, and made good his escape to Pennsylvania. He remained there some four months, when having made a fair experiment, and finding liberty among strangers, attended by the necessity of equal labor, and the responsibility of independence, not the golden life he had dreamed, he spontaneously returned to Virginia and to slavery. He is one out of a hundred for shrewdness, and this last act in our opinion, is not the least proof of it; for to those educated as slaves, and marked by nature if not for that end, yet with colors that establish an eternal barrier between them and the whites, liberty among the latter—a liberty attended with all the inconveniences and responsibility of free agency, without any of its benefits—is but a shadow, and not to be put in competition with the substantial comforts of the Virginia slave, and the exemption from prospective care which is concomitant of all slavery. This case, though but an isolated one, is we believe a fair illustration of the mild and benevolent character of Virginia slavery in general—and though we profess and really feel, the most ardent solicitude that the day may come when the soil of Virginia shall no longer be dug by slaves, and her character no longer be obnoxious to the reproach of holding human beings in bondage, yet that solicitude is created by our love and respect for our native State, and not by the expectation of ameliorating the condition of her slaves. Some little observation, and much enquiry, have long ago satisfied us, that the slaves of Virginia enjoy more solid comfort, are exposed to fewer hardships, than the laboring class of any portion of the Christian world. To exchange their condition for freedom to be enjoyed either in the U. States, in Africa, or the West Indies, would be subtracting materially, from the sum total of human happiness. It is the condition of their masters, weighed down and impoverished by the nature of negro slavery, and of Virginia blighted and held back in the glorious race of improvement and power, by the same cause, that impels us to pray for its final extinction and enlists our sympathies in behalf of colonization schemes.

Those who act in the same cause from the contrary motive—from sympathy for the slave himself—would do well to survey more closely, the masses of European wretchedness, before they permit the emotions of a gratuitous philanthropy to disturb their happiness.

What sub-type of article is it?

Slavery Abolition

What keywords are associated?

Virginia Slavery Runaway Slave Slave Comfort Emancipation Critique Colonization Schemes Paternalistic Defense

What entities or persons were involved?

Virginia Slaves Goochland County Pennsylvania Colonization Schemes

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Defense Of Virginia Slavery And Critique Of Emancipation

Stance / Tone

Pro Slavery Paternalism, Anti Abolitionist For Slaves' Sake

Key Figures

Virginia Slaves Goochland County Pennsylvania Colonization Schemes

Key Arguments

A Shrewd Runaway Slave Voluntarily Returned To Virginia Slavery After Experiencing Freedom In Pennsylvania. Liberty For Slaves Among Whites Offers Only Inconveniences Without Benefits, Unlike The Comforts Of Virginia Slavery. Virginia Slavery Is Mild And Benevolent, Providing More Solid Comfort Than Free Laborers In The Christian World. Emancipation Would Reduce Human Happiness For Slaves, Whether In The U.S., Africa, Or West Indies. Abolition Is Desired To Relieve The Impoverishment Of Masters And The Retardation Of Virginia's Progress, Not To Benefit Slaves. Sympathizers For Slaves Should Consider European Poverty Before Advocating Change.

Are you sure?