Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Independent Journal, Or, The General Advertiser
Editorial October 10, 1787

Independent Journal, Or, The General Advertiser

New York, New York County, New York

What is this article about?

Editorial from Pennsylvania Packet defends the new Federal Government against opposition, using historical examples like the English Revolution, Hanoverian accession, Scottish union, and American Independence to argue that such resistance is temporary and opponents will soon support it.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

From the Pennsylvania Packet.

Messrs. PRINTERS,

WHAT has been, will be, while men continue to be men, and there is nothing new under the sun. Some people seem alarmed at the opposition of a few weak and deluded men to the Federal Government; but if we look into the histories of our own and foreign countries, we shall find that there never was a revolution brought about in any country in favor of liberty or government, that was not opposed by ignorant or interested men.

The revolution that brought King William to the throne of England was effected by a majority of only three votes. Thousands opposed the accession of the Hanover family to the same throne some years afterwards. In 1715 and 1745 attempts were made to depose them, by an appeal to arms, which ended in the destruction of the leaders of the minority, and in the defeat of those brave and hardy mountaineers, who were seduced by those leaders into a rebellion, against the voice and interests of a majority of the people.

The union of the parliaments of England and Scotland was opposed by a strong majority of Scotland: recourse was had to arms by a few deluded men in the west of Scotland to prevent it. But they were soon prevailed upon to return in peace to their habitations, and in a few years afterwards joined with the majority of the nation, in praising the happy effects of the union.

The declaration of independence was opposed by a wealthy and powerful party, a whole state, and many counties in every state refused to concur in supporting it: and yet the independence of our country finally triumphed over all opposition.

I shall conclude, by repeating my first observation. What has been, will be, and there is nothing new under the sun. The present enemies of the federal government will ere long be its most zealous friends, and some of them, who are most prudent and silent about it or most clamorous against it, will probably soon fill its highest or most profitable offices.

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics Constitutional

What keywords are associated?

Federal Government Opposition Historical Revolutions English Revolution Scottish Union American Independence

What entities or persons were involved?

Federal Government King William Hanover Family Parliaments Of England And Scotland

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Opposition To The Federal Government

Stance / Tone

Optimistic Defense Of The Federal Government

Key Figures

Federal Government King William Hanover Family Parliaments Of England And Scotland

Key Arguments

Historical Revolutions In Favor Of Liberty Or Government Always Faced Opposition From Ignorant Or Interested Men English Revolution Succeeded By A Majority Of Three Votes Despite Opposition Attempts To Depose Hanoverians In 1715 And 1745 Failed Scottish Opposition To Union With England Was Overcome And Later Praised American Declaration Of Independence Triumphed Over Wealthy And Powerful Opposition Current Opponents Of The Federal Government Will Become Its Zealous Friends And Fill Its Offices

Are you sure?