Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
October 5, 1864
Brownlow's Knoxville Whig, And Rebel Ventilator
Knoxville, Knox County, Tennessee
What is this article about?
Extract from Dr. Lieber's letter in the New York Times criticizes the Chicago platform as endorsing Southern dominance, predicting McClellan's election would cause armistice, separation, national disintegration, and continued slavery, opposing the Union's ordained role.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
Dr. Lieber on the Chicago Platform.
The New York Times publishes the following philosophical and logical extract from a private letter, recently written by the eminent Dr. Lieber:
The Chicago platform appears to my mind the well-framed creed of Northern servility to the criminal arrogance of the South—a sanction of the highest-handed lawlessness. The election of General McClellan means armistice; armistice means separation; separation means disintegration—the instant separation of California, the dropping off of Utah, an empire in the Mississippi Valley, the excision of New England, and an inorganic clustering and reclustering of the Eastern Middle States without any inherent character. Disintegration means defiance to the wonderfully great and self-completing geography of our country, and a lapse into that state which befell Europe at the beginning of the Middle Ages, when principalities rose and fell, enduring only long enough to perpetuate the sanguinary turmoil: it means a repetition of the chronic revolution which has afflicted South America this half century, possibly with a neighbor growing in monarchic power, which soon would claim the right of extension and recuperation. Disintegration means the reckless rising against that polity which the Disposer of Events has ordained as the normal type of modern civilization, against the Nationalized Government, which is the opposite to the halting League, the vast, yet incoherent monarchy, the provincial kingdom, the petty city, State, and the fragmentary feudalism. It means quarreling, bloodshed and ruin, without an idea, for a century to come, and disgrace forever. It means the heartless destruction of a nation appointed to perform great and sacred tasks. It means all this and slavery to boot, that "divine institution" whose altar is the auction table, on which the undivine ties of parents and children are torn asunder by the auctioneer, who thus becomes a holy missionary of the worshipped institution.
The New York Times publishes the following philosophical and logical extract from a private letter, recently written by the eminent Dr. Lieber:
The Chicago platform appears to my mind the well-framed creed of Northern servility to the criminal arrogance of the South—a sanction of the highest-handed lawlessness. The election of General McClellan means armistice; armistice means separation; separation means disintegration—the instant separation of California, the dropping off of Utah, an empire in the Mississippi Valley, the excision of New England, and an inorganic clustering and reclustering of the Eastern Middle States without any inherent character. Disintegration means defiance to the wonderfully great and self-completing geography of our country, and a lapse into that state which befell Europe at the beginning of the Middle Ages, when principalities rose and fell, enduring only long enough to perpetuate the sanguinary turmoil: it means a repetition of the chronic revolution which has afflicted South America this half century, possibly with a neighbor growing in monarchic power, which soon would claim the right of extension and recuperation. Disintegration means the reckless rising against that polity which the Disposer of Events has ordained as the normal type of modern civilization, against the Nationalized Government, which is the opposite to the halting League, the vast, yet incoherent monarchy, the provincial kingdom, the petty city, State, and the fragmentary feudalism. It means quarreling, bloodshed and ruin, without an idea, for a century to come, and disgrace forever. It means the heartless destruction of a nation appointed to perform great and sacred tasks. It means all this and slavery to boot, that "divine institution" whose altar is the auction table, on which the undivine ties of parents and children are torn asunder by the auctioneer, who thus becomes a holy missionary of the worshipped institution.
What sub-type of article is it?
Partisan Politics
Slavery Abolition
War Or Peace
What keywords are associated?
Chicago Platform
Mclellan Election
National Disintegration
Slavery
Union Preservation
Civil War
What entities or persons were involved?
Dr. Lieber
General Mcclellan
South
North
New York Times
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Critique Of The Chicago Platform And Mcclellan Election
Stance / Tone
Strongly Anti Chicago Platform And Pro Union
Key Figures
Dr. Lieber
General Mcclellan
South
North
New York Times
Key Arguments
Chicago Platform Is Creed Of Northern Servility To Southern Arrogance
Election Of Mcclellan Means Armistice
Armistice Means Separation And Disintegration
Disintegration Leads To Fragmentation Like Medieval Europe Or South America
Opposes Nationalized Government Ordained For Modern Civilization
Results In Quarreling, Bloodshed, Ruin, And Perpetuation Of Slavery