Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Portland Gazette, And Maine Advertiser
Editorial January 28, 1811

Portland Gazette, And Maine Advertiser

Portland, Cumberland County, Maine

What is this article about?

Satirical critique of Congressman Willis Alston's argument on representation ratios in Congress, using a centipede analogy to mock the idea that large states' proportional losses justify small states' greater absolute losses.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Democratic Logic.—It is very liberal in the great states (said Mr. Willis Alston, a clear headed democratic member of Congress from North Carolina) to agree on a large number as the ratio of representation. For although the small states (Rhode-Island for instance) may lose one out of her two representatives, the large ones (Virginia for instance) will also lose one out of her twenty-two. On what principle Willis makes this calculation is not known. In order to induce him to "rise for explanation," we will take the liberty to state a case, and enquire of him whether it is in point. There is a little animal called Centipede, which has a hundred legs—Mr. Alston, (we will suppose for the sake of argument) has but two. Now, if to oblige their fellow animals, each of these creatures should consent to lose a leg, which would act with the greatest liberality, Willis, who would have but one left, or the Centipede, who would have ninety-nine?

What sub-type of article is it?

Satire Constitutional Partisan Politics

What keywords are associated?

Representation Ratio Congressional Debate Democratic Logic Satirical Analogy Small States Large States

What entities or persons were involved?

Willis Alston Congress Rhode Island Virginia North Carolina

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Mockery Of Representation Ratio Logic

Stance / Tone

Satirical Ridicule Of Democratic Argument

Key Figures

Willis Alston Congress Rhode Island Virginia North Carolina

Key Arguments

Large States' Proportional Losses Do Not Equate To Small States' Absolute Losses Analogy: Centipede Losing One Of 100 Legs Vs. Man Losing One Of Two Shows Unfairness

Are you sure?