Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Phenix Gazette
Story June 21, 1833

Phenix Gazette

Alexandria, Virginia

What is this article about?

A comparison of American orators Henry Clay and Daniel Webster to British counterparts Henry Brougham and Edmund Burke, arguing that Clay's passion rivals Brougham's, while Webster's philosophical depth mirrors Burke's, leading to enduring reputation rather than immediate political effect.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

If there is any true comparison, as regards vehemence and passion, between a living American and British orator, it lies between Mr. Clay and Mr. Brougham. Mr. Clay is the only public man in this country living that possesses these properties in such a degree as to rank him in the first order of speakers, while, if there is any proper parallel for Mr. Webster, in a British orator, it is to be found in Mr. Burke. Mr. Webster, like Mr. Burke, is an eminent instance of the range as well as depth of his views of society, and the true nature of its complicated relations.

Now Lord Brougham is scarcely ever lifted above the feelings and views of the partizan in his orations. This gives his harangues point and piquancy, while Mr. Webster can scarcely ever shuffle off the conviction that he is addressing feelings which ought to be permanent and universal. It is always found, therefore, that public speakers like Mr. Webster and Mr. Burke are too philosophical to be effective, as far as general conviction and immediate political action are concerned, while their orations possess that character, that what they lose in present power they gain in future reputation. Mr. Burke's speeches are now consulted as the consecrated repositories of the maxims of a comprehensive wisdom, and Mr. Webster's orations will go down to posterity recommended by the same high flavor of philosophy; while we doubt whether Lord Brougham's will be perused hereafter with any other relish than that which looks for enjoyment in the party triumphs of the scene and the hour.

—Southern Pat.

What sub-type of article is it?

Biography Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Moral Virtue Triumph

What keywords are associated?

Orators Comparison American British Speakers Philosophical Oratory Lasting Reputation Partisan Speeches

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Clay Mr. Brougham Mr. Webster Mr. Burke Lord Brougham Southern Pat.

Story Details

Key Persons

Mr. Clay Mr. Brougham Mr. Webster Mr. Burke Lord Brougham Southern Pat.

Story Details

The piece compares the oratory styles of Henry Clay to Henry Brougham for passion, and Daniel Webster to Edmund Burke for philosophical depth, suggesting the latter pair's speeches endure as wisdom repositories while Brougham's are partisan and fleeting.

Are you sure?