Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
June 29, 1846
Alexandria Gazette
Alexandria, Alexandria County, District Of Columbia
What is this article about?
This editorial warns of the electric telegraph's potential for misuse in speculation, news suppression, and gambling, advocating for its control by the Post Office Department under congressional law to prevent harm and ensure public benefit, citing the New York Express.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
THE MAGNETIC TELEGRAPH.
The electric Telegraph is capable of doing the greatest service to mankind, or it may do the greatest harm. If in the hands of bad men, or in the hands of men not bad, but who consider it their property, with which they have a right to do as they please, speculations should be undertaken in breadstuffs, or the necessaries of life,—what injustice might be done to the growers of produce, or to the producers at large! Or, if it should undertake the perversion of intelligence, or its suppression, what injury it might work in other and numerous ways! Stock gambling, bread gambling, or political gambling of the most frightful kind, may be carried on secretly by it, and successfully, too, often in the hands of adroit men, whose fortunes might be made by single operations. All, indeed, must grant that these, the perversions of its powers, may be monstrous, and that, therefore, it is an engine of mischief, as well as of good, that, like powder or the steam engine, ought to be under the control of law.
The possession of this great instrument of Thought and News, ought, then, as it seems to us, to be where we have, by the Constitution, intrusted the transmission of letters and newspapers, viz, in the Post Office Department. Congress should by general law, protect it and guard it in all the States. In time of war, or of domestic peril, it especially is necessary to the War and Navy Departments, or to the Executive power In time of peace, even, it is the proper medium through which all the heads of departments should communicate with their subordinates in the Custom Houses, Post Offices, &c. &c. But, surely, while standing as it is, isolated from the people, and independent of the people, capable of vast mischief, and unpunishable therefor, it should not be intrusted with high corporate powers, or be protected by law beyond any other property. In our admiration of the discovery, and our enthusiasm for its success, we should not bind chains about us, as we did when the locomotive first came along, and ran over its road of iron.—N. Y. Express.
The electric Telegraph is capable of doing the greatest service to mankind, or it may do the greatest harm. If in the hands of bad men, or in the hands of men not bad, but who consider it their property, with which they have a right to do as they please, speculations should be undertaken in breadstuffs, or the necessaries of life,—what injustice might be done to the growers of produce, or to the producers at large! Or, if it should undertake the perversion of intelligence, or its suppression, what injury it might work in other and numerous ways! Stock gambling, bread gambling, or political gambling of the most frightful kind, may be carried on secretly by it, and successfully, too, often in the hands of adroit men, whose fortunes might be made by single operations. All, indeed, must grant that these, the perversions of its powers, may be monstrous, and that, therefore, it is an engine of mischief, as well as of good, that, like powder or the steam engine, ought to be under the control of law.
The possession of this great instrument of Thought and News, ought, then, as it seems to us, to be where we have, by the Constitution, intrusted the transmission of letters and newspapers, viz, in the Post Office Department. Congress should by general law, protect it and guard it in all the States. In time of war, or of domestic peril, it especially is necessary to the War and Navy Departments, or to the Executive power In time of peace, even, it is the proper medium through which all the heads of departments should communicate with their subordinates in the Custom Houses, Post Offices, &c. &c. But, surely, while standing as it is, isolated from the people, and independent of the people, capable of vast mischief, and unpunishable therefor, it should not be intrusted with high corporate powers, or be protected by law beyond any other property. In our admiration of the discovery, and our enthusiasm for its success, we should not bind chains about us, as we did when the locomotive first came along, and ran over its road of iron.—N. Y. Express.
What sub-type of article is it?
Infrastructure
Legal Reform
Economic Policy
What keywords are associated?
Electric Telegraph
Government Regulation
Post Office Control
Speculation Risks
News Suppression
Stock Gambling
What entities or persons were involved?
Post Office Department
Congress
War And Navy Departments
N. Y. Express
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Regulation Of The Electric Telegraph By Government
Stance / Tone
Advocacy For Public Control To Prevent Misuse
Key Figures
Post Office Department
Congress
War And Navy Departments
N. Y. Express
Key Arguments
Telegraph Can Enable Unjust Speculations In Breadstuffs And Necessaries
Risk Of Perverting Or Suppressing Intelligence
Facilitates Secret Stock, Bread, Or Political Gambling
Should Be Under Legal Control Like Powder Or Steam Engine
Belongs In Post Office Department Per Constitution
Congress Must Protect And Guard It In All States
Essential For Government Communication In War And Peace
Should Not Receive Special Corporate Powers Or Protections