Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
July 27, 1791
Gazette Of The United States
New York, New York County, New York
What is this article about?
Satirical editorial ridicules modern critics denying Homer's existence, Swift's authorship of 'Tale of a Tub,' and the achievements of American patriots, accusing the latter of Tory-like depreciation.
OCR Quality
95%
Excellent
Full Text
COMMUNICATIONS.
Ten cities, it is said, contended for the honor of having been the birth place of Homer; but this contention, at the distance of more than twenty centuries, is found to have been about a non-entity. A modern French critic has discovered that no such person as Homer ever existed!-What illusions are played off upon the feelings of mankind—how has their sympathy been abused by reading such strains as the following :
" Can all the wreaths that crown'd his head,
"Compensate now to HOMER dead,
" The living HOMER's want of bread?
Another modern discovery is, that Dean Swift did not write the Tale of a Tub. We are not informed as to the circumstances which led to this discovery, but one obvious remark is obtruded on the mind, not very favorable to the reputation of the Dean, supposing the discovery to be well founded, and that is, the imposition which he put on mankind while living, and, owing to his incorrigible dishonesty, has been continued ever since his decease. Several petty robberies have been committed on the fame of Shakespeare; and we may expect every day to hear that Milton was not the author of Paradise Lost. But the assurance of some wonderfully sagacious modern politicians in their modern discoveries, exceeds all former examples. The patriots of America, whose wisdom and valor is emancipating the old world as it has already the new, have in a recent party publication been stripped of their laurels and their honors decreed them by a grateful country. -Their triumphs in the field, and that constitution which was the result of their combined wisdom, " were the productions of characters which will never enjoy the historical fame thereof." A most modest attempt truly to depreciate in the eyes of their countrymen, the patriots of America. If this is not Toryism, it is something that bears a strong resemblance to it.
Ten cities, it is said, contended for the honor of having been the birth place of Homer; but this contention, at the distance of more than twenty centuries, is found to have been about a non-entity. A modern French critic has discovered that no such person as Homer ever existed!-What illusions are played off upon the feelings of mankind—how has their sympathy been abused by reading such strains as the following :
" Can all the wreaths that crown'd his head,
"Compensate now to HOMER dead,
" The living HOMER's want of bread?
Another modern discovery is, that Dean Swift did not write the Tale of a Tub. We are not informed as to the circumstances which led to this discovery, but one obvious remark is obtruded on the mind, not very favorable to the reputation of the Dean, supposing the discovery to be well founded, and that is, the imposition which he put on mankind while living, and, owing to his incorrigible dishonesty, has been continued ever since his decease. Several petty robberies have been committed on the fame of Shakespeare; and we may expect every day to hear that Milton was not the author of Paradise Lost. But the assurance of some wonderfully sagacious modern politicians in their modern discoveries, exceeds all former examples. The patriots of America, whose wisdom and valor is emancipating the old world as it has already the new, have in a recent party publication been stripped of their laurels and their honors decreed them by a grateful country. -Their triumphs in the field, and that constitution which was the result of their combined wisdom, " were the productions of characters which will never enjoy the historical fame thereof." A most modest attempt truly to depreciate in the eyes of their countrymen, the patriots of America. If this is not Toryism, it is something that bears a strong resemblance to it.
What sub-type of article is it?
Satire
Partisan Politics
What keywords are associated?
Homer Existence
Swift Authorship
Shakespeare Fame
Milton Paradise Lost
American Patriots
Toryism
Historical Skepticism
What entities or persons were involved?
Homer
Dean Swift
Shakespeare
Milton
American Patriots
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Mockery Of Modern Historical Skepticism And Defense Of American Patriots
Stance / Tone
Satirical Defense Against Critics And Toryism
Key Figures
Homer
Dean Swift
Shakespeare
Milton
American Patriots
Key Arguments
Modern Critics Falsely Claim Homer Never Existed, Abusing Public Sympathy.
Discovery That Swift Did Not Write Tale Of A Tub Implies His Dishonesty.
Petty Attacks On Shakespeare's Fame, Potential Denial Of Milton's Authorship.
Recent Publication Strips American Patriots Of Deserved Honors.
Such Depreciation Resembles Toryism.