Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Salt Lake Herald
Story November 29, 1904

The Salt Lake Herald

Salt Lake City, Salt Lake County, Utah

What is this article about?

In San Francisco on Nov. 28, U.S. Circuit Judge Morrow dismissed the long-pending sugar rate case brought by the Interstate Commerce Commission against Southern Pacific and Union Pacific railroads, ruling the commission lacks legislative power to fix rates and the sugar freight rate to Kearney, Neb., was not shown unreasonable.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

NO LEGISLATIVE POWERS.

Interstate Commerce Commission Cannot Fix Rates.

San Francisco, Nov. 28.-The famous sugar rate case, which had been pending for several years, was dismissed today by United States Circuit Judge Morrow. In his opinion Judge Morrow exhaustively discusses the case and decides that the inter-state commerce commission is not vested with legislative powers to establish rates and that it had not been shown that the rate complained of on sugar from San Francisco to Kearney, Neb., was unreasonable per se. The suit was entitled the Inter-State Commerce Commission vs. the Southern Pacific company, the Union Pacific Railway company, and S. H. H. Clark, Oliver W. Mink, E. Ellery Anderson, John W. Doane and Frederick R. Coudert, as receiver of the Union Pacific Railway company, and the Union Pacific Railroad company, as successor of the Union Pacific Railway company.

This was a suit in equity to restrain the defendants from collecting certain freight charges on sugar in violation of the order of the inter-state commerce commission.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Justice

What keywords are associated?

Sugar Rate Case Interstate Commerce Commission Judge Morrow Railroad Freight Rates Legal Dismissal San Francisco Court

What entities or persons were involved?

Judge Morrow Interstate Commerce Commission Southern Pacific Company Union Pacific Railway Company S. H. H. Clark Oliver W. Mink E. Ellery Anderson John W. Doane Frederick R. Coudert

Where did it happen?

San Francisco

Story Details

Key Persons

Judge Morrow Interstate Commerce Commission Southern Pacific Company Union Pacific Railway Company S. H. H. Clark Oliver W. Mink E. Ellery Anderson John W. Doane Frederick R. Coudert

Location

San Francisco

Event Date

Nov. 28

Story Details

The Interstate Commerce Commission sued Southern Pacific and Union Pacific companies to restrain collection of allegedly unreasonable sugar freight rates from San Francisco to Kearney, Neb., violating commission orders. Judge Morrow dismissed the case after years, ruling the commission lacks legislative powers to establish rates and unreasonableness was not proven.

Are you sure?