Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Daily Phoenix
Editorial April 18, 1871

The Daily Phoenix

Columbia, Richland County, South Carolina

What is this article about?

An editorial critiques Radical Reconstruction policies, quoting the Boston Advertiser's call to empower Southern leaders of character to rebuild the South, arguing that current disfranchisement of intelligent whites and empowerment of ignorant blacks and whites invites Ku Klux violence and fails to foster stable governments.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Strange Words from a Strange Quarter.

In the course of an article deprecating with much earnestness the proposed measures now before Congress, for the suppression of the so-called Ku Klux outrages at the South, the Boston Advertiser, the leading Radical organ of Massachusetts, declares that: "The South must be reconstructed, if at all, by its natural leaders—the men of brains, character and influence—most of whom, of course, were in the late war."

This is sound policy. This opinion is held by hundreds of unprejudiced people—old army officers and citizens—who have lived and owned plantations in the South, or have traveled there.

The present state of things is very bad. We have been trying to create an unnatural state of affairs, and the result is a failure, so long as the only intelligent men are disfranchised, and the ignorant and vicious are permitted to control matters. All accounts agree that the hostility is not felt toward the National Government, but toward certain obnoxious black and white people.

Now, it is certainly too much to expect a very active public sentiment against the Ku Klux, if nothing better is promised than the grotesque travesties of governments which we have seen in many of these States.

Let us try a new remedy, and give brains, and character, and decency a chance. First of all, let us stop this wretched Congressional fooling with great communities as if they were babes or idiots. By attempting to subject whole States to the control of ignorant blacks and whites, who are both ignorant and vicious, we invite the very outrages of which we complain. The country is sick of the whole thing.

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics Crime Or Punishment Constitutional

What keywords are associated?

Reconstruction Ku Klux Outrages Southern Leaders Radical Policy Disfranchisement Congressional Measures

What entities or persons were involved?

Boston Advertiser Congress Ku Klux National Government Southern Leaders Radical Organ

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Advocacy For Reconstructing The South Using Its Natural Leaders Instead Of Radical Policies

Stance / Tone

Critical Of Current Reconstruction Efforts And Supportive Of Empowering Southern Men Of Brains And Character

Key Figures

Boston Advertiser Congress Ku Klux National Government Southern Leaders Radical Organ

Key Arguments

The South Must Be Reconstructed By Its Natural Leaders—Men Of Brains, Character, And Influence From The Late War. Current State Is Bad Due To Disfranchising Intelligent Men And Empowering Ignorant And Vicious People. Hostility Is Toward Obnoxious Black And White People, Not The National Government. Public Sentiment Against Ku Klux Is Weak Due To Grotesque State Governments. Propose Trying A New Remedy: Give Brains, Character, And Decency A Chance. Stop Congressional Interference Treating States As Babes Or Idiots. Subjecting States To Ignorant Control Invites Outrages. The Country Is Sick Of The Current Approach.

Are you sure?