Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Alexandria Gazette & Daily Advertiser
Domestic News December 1, 1817

Alexandria Gazette & Daily Advertiser

Alexandria, Virginia

What is this article about?

In Catskill, Jonathan Sickler was tried and acquitted for the 1813 murder of Sally Hamilton based on accomplice Thomas B. Lent's testimony, which proved contradictory; Sickler was discharged, and Lent committed for perjury.

Clipping

OCR Quality

92% Excellent

Full Text

From the Albany Daily Advertiser, Nov. 24.

GREENE OYER AND TERMINER.

On Thursday last, at the Circuit Court
and Court of Oyer and Terminer, held by
his honor Mr. Justice Van Ness, in Cats-
kill, Jonathan Sickler, charged by Tho-
mas B. Lent, an accomplice, with the
murder of Sally Hamilton, at Athens, on
the 25th of August, 1813, received his
trial and was acquitted. Since the con-
fession of Lent, last spring, much inte-
rest has been manifested by the public in
relation to the approaching trial. Many
were induced to believe, from the state-
ments of Lent, and from the exactness
with which many circumstances related
by him corresponded with those that ac-
tually occurred at the time of the sup-
posed murder, that Sickler could not es-
cape conviction. On the trial, however,
the examination of Lent was so replete
with contradictions, absurdities and im-
possibilities, and so feebly supported by
corroborating testimony, as to place the
innocence of the prisoner, as to the crime
for which he had been indicted, almost
beyond a doubt. Partaking, in a good
degree, of the general interest in regard
to this trial, the editor attended the Cir-
cuit for the purpose of furnishing the pub-
lic with a full report of it. The mass of
testimony which was adduced, will pre-
vent our giving it in full: but we shall
prepare a history of the trial from our
notes, which we believe will be satisfac-
tory. The examination of Lent alone
lasted a few minutes over five hours, and
the trial continued from 9 o'clock, A. M.
till 12 at night. Counsel for the prose-
cution, Moses I. Cantine, district attor-
ney, assisted by the attorney general.-
For the prisoner, Messrs. Williams and
Sudam.

On Friday Sickler was discharged from
prison, and Lent ordered to stand com-
mitted for perjury.

What sub-type of article is it?

Legal Or Court Crime

What keywords are associated?

Murder Trial Acquittal Perjury Catskill Court Sally Hamilton Murder

What entities or persons were involved?

Jonathan Sickler Thomas B. Lent Sally Hamilton Mr. Justice Van Ness Moses I. Cantine Williams Sudam

Where did it happen?

Catskill

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

Catskill

Event Date

Thursday Last

Key Persons

Jonathan Sickler Thomas B. Lent Sally Hamilton Mr. Justice Van Ness Moses I. Cantine Williams Sudam

Outcome

sickler acquitted and discharged from prison on friday; lent committed for perjury

Event Details

Jonathan Sickler tried for murder of Sally Hamilton at Athens on 25th August 1813, based on accomplice Thomas B. Lent's confession; Lent's testimony contradictory and unsupported, leading to acquittal

Are you sure?